Would You Send Your Child to Public Schools in Nashville?

Deciding whether to send your child to public schools in Nashville can be a daunting task, especially given the diverse opinions on the topic. My personal experience and understanding of the local education system suggest that certain factors play a crucial role in this decision. Here, I delve into the realities I face as a grandparent and city resident, sharing insights that may help others navigate this complex choice.

Public vs Private Schools in Nashville

When considering private schools, the belief that they are inherently superior academically or socially is not always justified. Based on feedback from former private school students, I hold a different perspective. The curriculum of public schools is designed to foster diversity in learning, and I believe this is essential for children who will live and work in a multicultural society. Public schools provide a diverse learning environment, which can be invaluable in preparing students for a wide range of future scenarios.

My Experience with Public Schools in Nashville

I moved to Nashville in 2014 with my son, and he spent five years in the Metro Public Schools system. During this time, he attended Donelson Middle School for two years and McGavock High School for three. While Donelson had a few good moments, McGavock was marked by many challenges.

A Decline in Educational Quality

During my son's time at McGavock, his academic performance declined dramatically. He went from receiving mostly A's and B's to barely passing. This stark contrast can be attributed to a few factors. The school staff, including principals, teachers, and administrative personnel, often spent more time trying to avoid incidents than actually teaching. Many of the students struggled with behavior issues, making it difficult for those who wanted to focus and learn.

The Role of the Principal

Despite the challenges, there was one positive note: the Principal, Robin Wall. According to various accounts, she was the only ray of hope in the school. However, the rest of the faculty seemed to lack the enthusiasm and dedication needed to create a conducive learning environment. This had a significant impact on my son's educational experience.

Safety Concerns and Parental Decisions

Given the safety concerns, especially in high schools like McGavock, many families are reconsidering the public school system. In 2021, I would send my child only if it was absolutely safe. The threats of violence, unruly behavior, and fear of shootings are real issues that deter many parents from enrolling their children in the public school system.

For working parents, the decision to send their children to public schools is even more challenging. It requires a lot of space for kids to play, which may not be feasible in some city environments. Moreover, the decision involves tough choices and sacrifices that many families are not willing to make.

Alternative School Choices

Considering these factors, I strongly recommend exploring alternative schools, such as charter schools. These schools often have smaller class sizes, which can improve the learning experience and ensure that every student receives individualized attention. If parents have the means, sending their children to charter schools or private institutions is a better option.

Conclusion

While I believe public schools play a vital role in providing educational opportunities to diverse communities, the current state of many public schools in Nashville highlights the need for improvements. Parents should carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks of public versus private schooling and consider the overall well-being of their child. Given the safety concerns and the quality of education, it may be wise to explore other options until more significant changes are implemented in the public school system.