Would Stannis Have Treated Gendry Differently if He Had Known Gendry Was Robert's Son?

In A Song of Ice and Fire and the corresponding series Game of Thrones, Stannis Baratheon's relationship with Gendry has been a topic of intense scrutiny and debate. The Baratheons and Stannis in particular, have been central in the political and emotional landscape of Westeros. However, it's often overlooked that Stannis would have treated Gendry differently if he had known Gendry was Robert's son.

Stannis Baratheon's Background and Motivations

Stannis, a man of strong conviction and unwavering belief in the theological governance of the Seven Kingdoms, has a history of infant abandonment and the perceived injustice of the denial of inherited rights. His family lineage, particularly his brother Renly and nephew Joffrey, have led him to question his self-worth and the legitimacy of his claims to the Iron Throne. In the show, Stannis knows that Gendry is Robert's son, but in the books, it's Eldric Storm who fills Gendry's role and is known to be Robert's true son. This discrepancy raises intriguing questions about how Stannis might act differently.

Gendry's Position in the Story

Firstly, it's crucial to establish Gendry's character. Full of potential and with a profound connection to his birthright as Robert's child, Gendry plays a significant role in ensuring continuity for the Baratheon line. He is a symbol of the rightful dynasty that the Starks aim to undermine, embodying the force that must be stopped to maintain their grip on power. Gendry’s birth being revealed as Robert's son adds another layer of complexity to his character, marking him as a potential threat or linchpin depending on Stannis' perspective.

Stannis's Motivations and His Relationship with Gendry

Secondly, Stannis's motivations play a critical role in his behavior. Throughout the series, he shows a disregard for personal connections and often treats those close to him with a certain detachment. This is rooted in his deep-seated belief that emotions and personal ties can lead to weakness, a belief he learned from his time serving under Robert Baratheon and the pact he made to win the Iron Throne. That Gendry is Robert's son could intensify Stannis's distaste for him, pushing him further away from showing him any special treatment or favorable regard.

The Context of Stannis's Knowledge and His Actions

Additionally, it is important to consider the timing and manner of Stannis's awareness. In Game of Thrones, Stannis knows that Gendry is Robert's son, but the revelation likely comes in a less confrontational or emotionally charged scenario. This could mean that Stannis is less likely to exhibit a paternal instinct or softer approach towards Gendry. The books, however, do not delve into Stannis's explicit knowledge of Eldric's identity, which could significantly shift his stance. If Stannis knew Gendry was Robert's true son, he might have hesitated before offering him the room at Dragonstone that he provides to other Baratheons.

Surrounding Influences and Comparisons

Stannis's actions towards Gendry also reflect the broader context of his reign. His strict governance and rigid adherence to principle would likely manifest in a more harsh or distant treatment of Gendry, especially if he recognized him as Robert's son. For instance, his stance on the legitimacy of propriety and hereditary rights is evident in his refusal to accept his brother Renly's claim to the throne, treating Renly with a similar detachment. This could extend to his treatment of Gendry, viewed through the lens of shared lineage with his deceased brother.

Closing Thoughts

Considering the complexities and motivations involved, Stannis's treatment of Gendry would indeed be markedly different if he had known Gendry was Robert's son. Stannis's devotion to the principles of justice and his desire to restore rightful rule would likely result in a colder, less personal interaction with someone who is viewed as a rival to his claim. While he provides shelter and resources, the very knowledge of Gendry's significant lineage under Robert could push Stannis to maintain a stricter and less favorably inclined relationship with him. These considerations add depth to our understanding of Stannis's character and the strategic positioning of Gendry in the ongoing conflict for Westeros.

By highlighting these points, we deepen our appreciation for the intricate interplay of power, legacy, and personal relationships within the world of A Song of Ice and Fire and Game of Thrones.