Would Remaking 'Being There' Work with Adam Sandler or Rob Schneider?
When Peter Sellers starred in the 1979 film Being There, he perfectly embodied the character of Chance Gardener, a simple gardener who inadvertently becomes an influential figure. Would the film hold up if it were remade with contemporary actors like Adam Sandler or Rob Schneider?
The Problem with Modern Interpretations
The answer is no. Neither Sandler nor Schneider would be able to convey the same depth of character that Peter Sellers achieved. Sellers was a natural in comedic roles, offering both wit and wisdom, making his character of Chance convincing and relatable.
The Characteristics of a Successful Remake
Suturing a comedic character with profoundness is no easy feat. Sellers excelled in this, portraying a character who appeared simplistic yet held a deeper, unspoken understanding of the world. Sandler and Schneider, while skilled actors, are not in the same league as Sellers and have different comedic styles. Sandler, for example, might decaying into expressions that blend deftness with sentimentality, while Schneider’s portrayal might be too obvious and comedic to take Chance seriously.
The Essence of the Original
The original film was a masterpiece, and its strength lay in the depth of the character of Chance. Only those who had never seen the original would find a remake compelling. Sellers' performance was flawless, creating a character whose simplicity and wisdom resonated with audiences, even though he himself was unaware of his profound impact.
Preserving the Unconscious Profoundness
One of the most striking aspects of Chance’s character is his ability to convey profound wisdom without realizing its depth. Sellers delivered this nuance perfectly, making viewers believe in Chance’s innate understanding. Any attempt to remake the film with a modern actor would struggle to maintain this depth, as the audience would quickly pick up on the actor's broader comedic strokes.
Steve Carrell: A Possible Choice
While no remake could truly capture the essence of Sellers' performance, one actor who might come close is Steve Carrell. Carrell is known for his comedic finesse and has the ability to convey a wide range of emotions. If Carrell were to take on the role, he would need to find the right balance between comedy and depth, making Chance seem both subtle and profound.
Recollections and Conclusion
Reflecting on the original film, it’s evident that Chance’s character works because of the subtle and nuanced performances. Both his appearance and mannerisms suggest someone who might deliver profound and cryptic statements. While a remake could potentially involve actors known for broad comedy, it would be a stretch for them to convey the same level of depth.
In conclusion, the Being There of Peter Sellers remains unparalleled. Any attempt to remake it with contemporary actors would likely fall short, as the original's success lies in the unique blend of comedy and depth that Sellers masterfully delivered.