Will Rockstar Make a New Red Dead Prequel or Continue with Jack Marston's Story?

The franchise's future is one of the most discussed topics among fans of the Red Dead series. This rage-inducing question has sparked numerous debates online, with opinions dividing into two primary camps:

Will They Create a Prequel?

One school of thought leans towards a prequel in the American Revolutionary War era. Fans argue that this period offers a wealth of historical detail and potential for unique storytelling. The historical aspects, such as new fashion systems, revised firearms, and authentic locations, could be fascinating and offer a fresh take on the Red Dead Revolution concept. Additionally, the historical figures, like George Washington, could add depth to the narrative. However, this option faces its own challenges, particularly with the setting being too modern for the franchise's unique tone.

Moreover, there is a significant amount of fan-driven content already exploring how such a game could be developed through existing mods that redesign RDR2 to reflect the American Revolutionary War period.

Will They Continue with Jack Marston's Story?

The other camp believes that continuing the story of Jack Marston, the obnoxious and unlikable protagonist from Red Dead Redemption 2, is not the best route. Critics argue that Jack is a boring and uninteresting character, there is nothing compelling left to explore in his story, and continuing with him would result in a repetitive and unoriginal experience.

Furthermore, the Red Dead series is as much about the decline of the old West as it is about its romanticized portrayal. By 1914, the Wild West had long ceased to exist, and placing Jack Marston in that setting would feel anachronistic. The redemption arcs in RDR1 and RDR2 are critical to the narrative, and they are not present in Jack's character, making him an unsuitable protagonist for a new entry in the franchise.

The Red Dead Franchise and Future Directions

Some argue that the franchise should be seen as the Red Dead franchise rather than a direct continuation of Red Dead Redemption. This perspective sees Red Dead Revolver as the first game in the series, with Red Dead Redemption being its spiritual successor. Therefore, a new Red Dead game would more appropriately follow a different timeline or create new characters, as this would align with the franchise's evolution outside of a prequel or continuation of the Marston saga.

Conclusion and Future Speculation

In conclusion, based on Rockstar's track record and the challenges associated with prequels or continuations, it is more likely that a new Red Dead game would introduce fresh storylines and new characters. This approach would offer a breath of fresh air, avoid the pitfalls of familiar plots, and maintain the franchise's unique identity. Fans should remain hopeful for new and innovative storytelling that can stand on its own and embrace the vast possibilities that a new setting can bring.

Keywords: Red Dead Redemption 3, Red Dead Revolution, Red Dead Prequel