Why Steve Rogers is Called the First Avenger Despite Carol Danvers Being a Key Figure in the Avengers Initiative

In the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), Steve Rogers, better known as Captain America, is hailed as the

Historical Context

Historically, Steve Rogers, otherwise known as Captain America, was active during World War II, making him one of the earliest examples of a modern superhero. In contrast, Carol Danvers, who takes on the identity of Captain Marvel, emerges onto the scene much later, in the 1990s.

Avengers Initiative

While it is true that Nick Fury was inspired by Carol Danvers to form a group of powerful individuals to fight future threats, the Avengers Initiative was a response to a broader range of threats. The initiative itself was a call for a team of superheroes to protect Earth from alien and supervillain threats. Nick Fury recognized the need for a well-organized group of heroes to coordinate their efforts effectively.

Legacy and Symbolism

Steve Rogers’ character symbolizes the ideals of heroism, bravery, and sacrifice. His legacy as a war hero and his role in the formation of the first official superhero team in the MCU make him a significant figure in the narrative timeline. Therefore, Steve is referred to as the First Avenger because he is the first official superhero in the MCU from the 1950s, during which time he fought for his country and the world.

Timeline and Recognition

While Carol Danvers was a key figure in later events, such as the battle against the Kree, Captain America was the first to be officially recognized as a superhero. The MCU timeline shows that Steve Rogers was active from the 1940s, long before the modern superheroes of the MCU became prominent. Thus, when Steve reappeared in 2012, he was already well-established as a symbol of heroism.

Character Distinctions

Another argument supporting Steve as the First Avenger is the way his character embodies the essence of what it means to be a superhero. In Captain America: The First Avenger, his actions and bravery in World War II were legendary. Additionally, Steve Rogers is the protagonist of a standalone film, and his arc is a central part of the MCU narrative. This distinguishes him from characters like Thor, who, while ancient, does not have the same direct connection to the formation of the Avengers.

Furthermore, Carol Danvers, while crucial in the fight against extraterrestrial threats, was not included in the original Avengers roster. Nick Fury established the Avengers Initiative to bring together the best of the best, and Steve Rogers was the first of these.

In essence, while Carol Danvers played a crucial role in the modern context of the Avengers, Steve Rogers’ legacy and historical significance mean he is rightfully referred to as the First Avenger in the MCU.

Understanding the historical context, the significance of legacy, and the timing of events in the MCU clearly positions Steve Rogers as the archetypal First Avenger, despite the prominent role played by Carol Danvers in later developments.