Why 'Star Trek: Discovery' Isn't More Popular: An SEO-Optimized Analysis
The enduring appeal of Star Trek has been a cornerstone of science fiction entertainment for decades. However, some fans might ask, why isn't Star Trek: Discovery as popular as its predecessor series? While many YouTube videos and articles delve into this topic, here's a concise yet detailed analysis:
Departure from the Canon of OldTrek
Long-time Star Trek aficionados might argue that Star Trek: Discovery feels like a significant departure from the canon established by Roddenberry and Berman. By redefining the future and testing the boundaries of what constitutes Star Trek, the new series has alienated a substantial portion of its fanbase. For these viewers, it feels less like a natural progression and more like a betrayal. Even attempts to rationalize these changes through the multiverse concept have not been well-received. Fans are left feeling alienated, as their cherished canon is rewritten and disregarded.
Overly Preachy Social Issues
Star Trek: Discovery has been criticized for its explicit and preachy approach to social issues, particularly regarding gender and diversity. In contrast, older Star Trek series handled these themes more subtly and organically. For example, newer characters like Tilly, who is portrayed as both overweight and unintelligent, have been a significant source of frustration for many viewers. This portrayal not only detracts from the characters' viability in a Starfleet academy but also reinforces outdated stereotypes. Moreover, the emphasis on gender dynamics often feels forced and undercurrents of discrimination are prevalent, which some argue detracts from the genuine camaraderie that made past series so compelling.
Visual Aesthetics and Crew Dynamics
Visually, Star Trek: Discovery has been described as lacking the warmth and charm of classic series. The stark, cold color palette and sterile look of the bridge contrast drastically with the warmer, more inviting tones of Deep Space Nine, The Next Generation, and Voyager. This visual discrepancy is particularly jarring, given the absence of the kind of emotional investment in the crew that made these series so endearing. Long-term fans often connect with the characters' personalities and relationships, which in Discovery, feel less personal and more formal.
Unbearable Lead Character and Charisma Absence
One of the most significant criticisms is the portrayal of Michael Burnham, the series' lead character. Her constant whining and emotional volatility make her an extremely unlikeable protagonist, drawing comparisons to unpopular characters from other series like Nelix in Voyager and Reg Barclay in The Next Generation. Even the addition of Tilly and other minor characters has only added to the list of flaws in the series. In comparison, earlier Star Trek captains like Picard, Kirk, and Archer exuded charisma and a magnetic appeal that made them absolute idols for fans. With Discovery, there is no character that garners similar admiration or inspires similar enthusiasm.
Poor Production Quality
Many fans have also criticized the overall quality of Star Trek: Discovery, citing poor writing, underwhelming acting, and weak casting. The production values, often described as being on par with lower-budget projects, have failed to meet the standards set by older series. This perception of a lack of polish and attention to detail has further marginalized the show in the eyes of many long-time fans.