Why Some Hollywood Critics Show Bias When Ben Affleck Plays a Hispanic Character

The debate over the casting of actors in roles that align with their cultural background often highlights a peculiar double standard within the entertainment industry. Recently, some critics have expressed outrage when actors, such as Ben Affleck, take on Hispanic roles, while simultaneously overlooking similar instances involving other actors like Andy Garcia, Lynda Carter, Frankie Muniz, Anya Taylor-Joy, Vinessa Shaw, Eiza González, and Bella Thorne. This article delves into the reasoning behind this bias, using a comparative analysis of casting issues.

The Double Standard in Casting

The concern over the casting of Ben Affleck in a Hispanic role is palpable, but it is not unique. Critics have a hit-or-miss attitude towards casting choices, often showing a preference for Hispanic actors to play roles that they might otherwise consider unfeasible. This selective outrage raises questions about the true motives behind such criticism.

Real-Life Examples of Bias

Let's take a closer look at some of these examples:

Ben Affleck: When Ben Affleck played a Hispanic character, critics pointed out his lack of direct Hispanic heritage. However, even more notably, many Hispanic actors like Andy Garcia, Frankie Muniz, Anya Taylor-Joy, Vinessa Shaw, Eiza González, and Bella Thorne have been cast in predominantly White roles without the same level of scrutiny. Hollywood Norms: The same critics have no issues with actors like Natalie Wood, Katherine Hepburn, and Marlon Brando playing non-Hispanic roles. These examples involve Russo-American actresses and actors playing diverse ethnicities, yet the critics overlook the potential casting of Hispanic actors in similar roles.

The double standard is apparent; there is an expectation for Hispanic actors to take on diverse roles, while other actors have a more flexible approach to their own ethnicity and cultural background.

The Argument Against Bias

Critics argue that there are fewer roles specifically cast for Hispanic actors, hence the rationale for them going to Hispanic actors. This argument suggests that the industry is not doing enough to diversify its casting pool, and thus, when opportunities do arise, they should be taken advantage of.

However, the argument overlooks the fact that there is no inherently discriminatory barrier against white actors playing Hispanic roles. Jewish actors have a history of playing white roles, and Hispanic actors have the capability to play white roles. The issue lies more with the industry's choices and the public's scrutiny of these choices.

Conclusion

The core of the bias is rooted in the selective outrage towards certain casting choices. The industry and its critics need to ensure that casting is based on merit and the needs of the roles rather than the perceived ethnicity of the actor. Until then, these double standards will continue to plague discussions around diversity and inclusion in Hollywood.