Why Some Dislike Zack Snyder's Superman in DC Extended Universe
The character of Superman has held a special place in many hearts for years, and while some maintain a deep love for the Man of Steel, others share a different opinion. One of the most discussed versions of Superman is his appearance in the DC Extended Universe, particularly in Zack Snyder's films like 'Man of Steel' and 'Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice' (Director's Cut and the 4-hour version). While many admire the physical transformation and the grand scale of these films, some viewers find Zack Snyder's interpretation of Superman to be lacking in several key areas. This article delves into the reasons why some people dislike the version of Superman created by Zack Snyder in DCEU.
Action and Casualties in Fight Scenes
One of the main criticisms of Zack Snyder's Superman is the nature of his fight scenes and the treatment of collateral damage. For instance, in 'Man of Steel', instead of flying off or engaging the enemy in an open field where the spectacle and impact would be minimal, Superman chooses to fight the gang in a town. This results in unnecessary casualties, which some viewers do not appreciate. The focus on these scenes seems to prioritize action over the well-being of innocent lives, which can be seen as in poor taste.
Lack of Moral Conviction
A more significant concern arises from Superman's actions, or lack thereof, in crucial moments. In 'Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice' (Director's Cut) and 'Justice League', Superman is often depicted as hesitant and even morally ambiguous. For example, while he is capable of easily defeating Zod, he chooses not to do so when Zod commits mass destruction and murder. This decision-making leaves viewers questioning the integrity and morality of Superman, a character traditionally known for his unwavering commitment to justice and protection of innocent lives.
Character Development and Emotional Depth
Another issue stems from the lack of emotional depth in Snyder's portrayal of Superman. Unlike the optimistic, selfless, and inspiring Superman introduced by Christopher Reeve, Snyder's Superman is often portrayed as a haunted, grief-stricken figure who cannot come to terms with his human heritage. This version of Superman struggles with his identity, doubt, and the weight of his powers, leading to a character that feels less relatable and genuine. The contrast between the early depictions of Superman and Snyder's vision creates a sense of disappointment for fans.
Fan Queas at Snyder’s Vision and Reboot
Despite the grand scale and production values of Zack Snyder's DCEU films, many fans are queasy about the direction in which the storylines and character development have gone. The focus on building an overarching narrative more akin to past Marvel films sacrifices character depth and individual storylines. This results in a disjointed narrative that loses sight of the unique appeal of DC's heroes. Additionally, the decision to reboot Superman with James Gunn signals a return to the traditional and beloved superhero formula that many feel would correct the issues with Snyder's vision.
However, it is important to note that not all fans share these views. Superman is a beloved character with a unique allure, and the DCEU/Man of Steel films have both their admirers and detractors. Each version of Superman brings its own set of strengths and weaknesses, and the evolving narrative of the DCEU continues to develop.
Conclusion
The version of Superman created by Zack Snyder in DCEU is a subject of both praise and criticism. While the visual spectacle and the world-building have captivated many, the lack of moral integrity, emotional depth, and the focus on grand scale over character development have led to a mixed reception. As the DCEU continues to evolve, it remains to be seen how well the reboot with James Gunn will resonate with audiences, and whether it will finally deliver the character of Superman that fans have longed for.
Keywords: Zack Snyder, Superman, DC Extended Universe (DCEU), Man of Steel