Why Some Disapprove of Zendaya in Disney's Ariel Role for 'The Little Mermaid' Remake

The upcoming live-action remake of The Little Mermaid has stirred significant debate, particularly around the casting of Zendaya as the iconic character Ariel. Many fans are questioning why some are opposed to this choice. In this article, we will explore the various reasons behind this controversy, focusing on race, audience expectations, and issues related to preserving the original story.

Racial Diversity and Representation

One of the primary concerns surrounding Zendaya's casting as Ariel is the issue of race. The Little Mermaid was originally an animated film, but character representation matters, especially given Hollywood's historical tendency towards whiteness in casting. Many stakeholders and viewers have advocated for a more diverse cast to reflect the changing demographics of the audience and to promote inclusiveness. Despite Zendaya's biracial background, which includes both African American and Latino heritage, some have argued that she does not fit the traditional image of someone "visibly black." This raises questions about the importance of racial representation and the challenges of casting within a multi-cultural context.

Expectations and Youthfulness

Another significant point of contention is the age and perceived experience of Zendaya compared to other potential candidates. Longtime fans of the original animated series may have expected a younger actor to play Ariel. Zendaya, although talented and experienced, has played significant roles well into her twenties. This has led some to question whether she is the right age for the character, despite her proven abilities as an actress, dancer, and singer. The expectation of a younger, more traditional portrayal stems from the original movie's leading lady, Jodi Benson, who played Ariel at a relatively young age.

Preserving the Source Material

Perhaps the most deeply emotional argument against Zendaya playing Ariel revolves around the preservation of the original source material. The Little Mermaid holds a special place in popular culture and has become an enduring symbol for many fans. To some, remaking the film in any way, especially by changing a beloved character like Ariel, is seen as a betrayal of the original story. This group feels strongly about maintaining the integrity of the characters and storyline as they remember them. Such changes, they argue, could lead to disappointment, resentment, or even a loss of interest in the film among long-time fans.

Alternative Controversies: Zoey Deschanel

While these are the primary concerns, there has also been discussion about why Zoey Deschanel did not get the role. Reports suggest that Deschanel had publicly expressed interest and support for the project well before official casting announcements. Some have argued that her voice and personality would have been a better fit for Ariel, and that her involvement would have resonated more with the fanbase. However, it appears that Disney made a different choice, leading to the current situation with Zendaya in the lead role.

These controversies highlight the complexities and sensitivities involved in casting decisions for beloved classic films. The impact of changing roles and characters can be multifaceted, touching on issues of race, audience expectations, and fan loyalty. As the premiere approaches, the outcome will reveal much about how these tensions play out in the real world of entertainment.