Why Some Consider Hamlet or Shakespeare’s Plays as Bad Literature

William Shakespeare, hailed as one of the greatest playwrights in the English language, has faced criticism over his works throughout history. While many hold his plays in high regard, others perceive them as bad literature. This article delves into the various reasons why certain individuals and critics have found Shakespeare's plays, particularly Hamlet, to be less engaging or less enjoyable.

Criticism of Shakespeare’s Plays

Language and Accessibility

One of the primary criticisms of Shakespeare’s work is the use of Early Modern English, which can present a barrier for contemporary readers and audiences. The dense and archaic language may be difficult to understand, leading to frustration and a perception that the plays lack accessibility. Despite their profound literary value, the complexity of the language can make the plays less engaging for some viewers.

Pacing and Structure

Another point of contention is the pacing and structure of Shakespeare’s plays. Some critics argue that the slow and deliberate progression of events can make the narrative feel tedious or disjointed. This can be particularly true for plays like Hamlet, which features a complex and extended storyline that may not resonate with all audiences. The thematic depth and psychological complexity can be overwhelming, leading to a perception that the plays lack concise and straightforward storytelling.

Characterization and Relatability

The characterization in Shakespeare’s plays, especially Hamlet, has also faced criticism. While many praise the depth and complexity of the characters, others argue that they can be inconsistent or overly introspective. This can make the characters less relatable, leading to a lack of engagement. Hamlet, known for his philosophical musings and indecisiveness, is a prime example of a character who may not appeal to everyone due to his introspective nature.

Cultural Relevance

Shakespeare’s themes and social contexts may seem outdated or irrelevant to modern audiences. The moral dilemmas and societal issues presented in his plays may not resonate with contemporary readers, leading to a sense of disconnection. For instance, the themes of revenge and duty may feel distant from today’s world, making the plays appear more academic than engaging.

Overexposure and Fatigue

The overexposure of Shakespeare’s works has also contributed to a sense of fatigue among some audiences. With Shakespeare being a required reading in schools and frequently performed, there is a risk of backlash against the perceived overhyped status of his plays. This can lead to a sense that the works are familiar and predictable, lacking the novelty and surprise that younger audiences might appreciate.

Personal Taste

Lastly, it is important to recognize that literature, like all forms of art, is highly subjective. Some individuals simply prefer different styles, genres, or themes that resonate more with their personal experiences and preferences. Shakespeare, while widely celebrated, may not align with everyone’s tastes or reading habits.

While Shakespeare is undoubtedly a towering figure in English literature, these criticisms highlight the varying responses his works elicit from different audiences. Understanding these perspectives can offer a broader appreciation for the diverse interpretations of literary value.