Why Should Biden Step Down Immediately: An Imminent Election Dilemma
The debate surrounding whether President Biden should step down immediately or leave Vice President Kamala Harris as the acting President during the upcoming election has been a contentious one, particularly within the Democratic Party. As the election draws closer, several key issues related to presidential continuity, political logic, and electoral integrity have emerged. This article aims to discuss the rationale behind these debates and the logical implications of each possible action.
The Democratic Party's Stance and Its Motivations
Some Democrats advocate for Vice President Kamala Harris to serve as the acting President for a brief period. Their motivations are varied and multifaceted. Some believe that the appointment of the first woman President, or the first female black President, is crucial for representation and historical significance. Others argue that this should be done to 'stick it to the opposing party' and disrupt the traditional numbering sequence of Presidents.
Legal and Practical Considerations
However, the legal and practical implications of stepping down immediately are significant. For instance, there is no clear logic for making Harris the President when the new President will take office in just 8 weeks. Many have pointed out that this contradicts the established norms and procedures in place. The precedent set by Bill Clinton’s administration, where Vice President Al Gore did not become President despite losing the election, highlights this point.
Political Motivations and Potential Pitfalls
Another motivation is to save Vice President Harris from the embarrassment of certifying the Presidential Election, which is scheduled for January 6th. However, there are numerous legal and procedural safeguards in place to address this concern. She could avoid certifying the election by skipping the meeting and allowing the President pro tempore of the Senate to preside over the Joint Session.
Historical Precedents
Historically, Vice President Herbert Humphrey was spared the embarrassment of certifying the election of Richard Nixon in 1968. Instead, he led a funeral delegation in Europe for an ex-Secretary General of the UN who had died. Similarly, in 2028, if Kamala Harris were to become a frontrunner for the Democratic nomination, her potential role as an ex-President could influence the race, but for now, her immediate role as Vice President remains the focus.
The Incumbent President's Health and the 25th Amendment
President Biden, at 81 years old and in declining health, raises the question of potential succession. However, the Cabinet has not invoked the 25th Amendment, which would establish a clear line of succession. Unless there is a health crisis or the President dies, the need for immediate succession does not seem imminent. The current Vice President and the Cabinet are committed to seeing President Biden through his term.
Conclusion: Practical and Legal Perspectives
Given the practical and legal considerations, there are no strong reasons for President Biden to step down immediately. The current arrangement, with Vice President Harris serving as acting President, is within the bounds of established legal frameworks and maintains the continuity of government. Moreover, the possibility of a divided or a Republican-controlled Congress complicates any efforts to confirm a new Vice President in less than eight weeks into the new term.
In summary, while the debate over the immediate stepping down of President Biden is fervent, the practical and legal implications suggest that the incumbent should remain in office until the term concludes naturally. This approach aligns with constitutional principles and maintains the integrity of the electoral process.