Why NFL Broadcast Teams Sound So Subdued on TV
The difference in the broadcasting styles between radio and television, specifically in the context of NFL games, can be attributed to several factors. This article explores these factors and delves into how the nature of the medium, production choices, audience expectations, and personal styles contribute to the distinct tone of on-air commentary.
The Role of the Medium
The medium differences play a significant role in shaping the broadcasting style. On radio, there is a reliance on the announcer to convey the excitement of the game since visual elements are limited. This necessitates a more enthusiastic style to engage listeners. In contrast, television broadcasts utilize visual elements like multiple camera angles, replays, and graphics to convey the excitement. These visual aids enable the commentators to take a more subdued approach, allowing viewers to focus on these elements.
Technical aspects of production choices also influence the style of broadcasting. TV broadcasts often involve intricate camera work, replays, and graphics that can carry the excitement of the game. Producers may prefer a more measured commentary style to help viewers appreciate these visual elements without being overwhelmed by enthusiastic commentary.
Comprehending Audience Expectations
The audience for TV broadcasts has different expectations. Viewers might prefer a more analytical approach that provides insights into the game rather than just excitement. Commentators like Troy Aikman and Joe Buck often balance play-by-play with analysis, leading to a more composed delivery. This style not only aligns with the production goals but also resonates with a broader audience, offering a balanced presentation of the game.
Personal Broadcasting Styles
Individual announcers have their own styles and personalities. Aikman and Buck, for example, are known for their calm and professional demeanor, which may not convey the same level of excitement as radio announcers who often adopt a more hyperbolic style. This personal style can significantly impact the perceived enthusiasm of the broadcast.
Longevity and Consistency
Adjusments in style over time to maintain a consistent tone throughout the game can also lead to a more subdued delivery. Established broadcasters aim to provide a steady narrative rather than peak excitement for every play. This long-term consistency further contributes to the subdued nature of on-TV commentary.
Additional Responsibilities
Television commentators have a wider range of responsibilities during the broadcast, including providing pre-game and halftime analysis, conducting interviews with players and coaches, and more. These additional tasks can contribute to a more subdued style of commentary as commentators need to balance their roles and not overshadow the visual elements of the game.
It is also important to note that different commentators have varying styles and personalities. What one person finds subdued or low-key may be perceived differently by others. Some may prefer a more reserved and analytical approach, while others may adopt a more energetic and enthusiastic style.
Finally, the goal of the broadcast team is to appeal to a broad audience. A more subdued style may be more palatable for a wider range of viewers, ensuring a consistent and engaging experience for everyone.