Why Doesn't Remus Lupin Reach Out to Harry Before He Joins Hogwarts?

The magic of the Harry Potter universe is filled with complex relationships and deep struggles. One of the intriguing plot points surrounds the interactions between Remus Lupin and Harry Potter. Why doesn't Remus reach out to Harry before he is hired as a Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher at Hogwarts? This question delves into the personal struggles, connections to the past, and the lack of knowledge that make this a poignant and pivotal moment in the series.

Personal Struggles

Remus Lupin has been on a journey of personal growth and struggle. One of his most significant challenges involves his status as a werewolf, a condition that carries a considerable stigma both in the wizarding and Muggle worlds. Living a somewhat isolated life since his school days, Remus may have found it complicated or overwhelming to reach out to Harry. The emotional and practical complexities of his condition would naturally impact his decision-making process, making it difficult to form new connections.

Connection to the Past

Remus was close friends with Harry's parents, James and Lily Potter, but after their tragic deaths, he may have felt a profound sense of loss and guilt. The arrival of Harry, a living reminder of his lost friends, could have added another layer of complexity to his emotions. He might have been uncertain about how to approach Harry, knowing that he is a key figure in fulfilling the prophecy, much like his parents.

Lack of Knowledge

Another significant factor is the lack of knowledge about Harry's situation and daily life. Remus had lived away from the wizarding community, seeking a cure for his condition, and may not have been privy to the full extent of Harry's struggles at the Dursleys. His isolation and distance could have hindered his ability to understand and empathize with Harry's situation.

Hogwarts Position

Remus's decision to return to Hogwarts as a Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher provides him with a structured opportunity to reconnect with Harry and the other members of the Order of the Phoenix. This role allows him to be part of Harry's life in an official capacity rather than merely as a personal mentor or guardian. His new position at Hogwarts fulfills his desire to help and at the same time, offers a structured environment that could help him, and Harry, with their respective challenges.

Other Reasons for Hesitation

There are several other reasons for Remus's hesitation:

Harry's Guardians: Pettigrew, who was captured by the Dursleys, did not live with the Dursleys. Moreover, Remus likely thought that Pettigrew was dead. This adds another layer of complexity to the situation, making it less likely for Remus to reach out without confirmation. Dumbledore's Advice: Dumbledore may have advised Remus not to contact Harry, either due to safety reasons or to keep the focus on Harry's immediate guardians. Harry's Location: For a decade, Remus had no idea where Harry was. He would assume that someone else, like a more distant relative, had taken care of Harry. His lack of familiarity with Muggle society might have made it difficult for him to find out about Harry's relatives. Mental and Practical Barriers: If Remus did go looking for Harry, he might have inadvertently led a Death Eater right to Harry's friends or needlessly terrified his guardian. This would not only heighten the risks but also bring unnecessary suffering. His Own Life: With the war ending, the Order of the Phoenix did not need Remus. The loss of his friends, including James, who promised to help him, and the Ministry's hostility towards werewolves, forced Remus to prioritize his own life. Finding a secure place for his transformations was a priority, and a flat in a town would not suffice. Internal Conflict: Remus never spotted the traitor among them and may have felt guilty. The Order discredited him after the Potters went into hiding, and he might never have seen Harry again. Remus could have told himself that he barely remembered the boy and that Harry did not need him.

In conclusion, Remus Lupin's hesitance to reach out to Harry is a multifaceted issue rooted in personal struggles, emotional connection to the past, lack of knowledge, and practical and mental barriers. Understanding these factors provides deeper insight into the character's decisions and the intricate nature of the Harry Potter universe.