Why Does Death Stranding Have Such Divisive Reviews?

Introduction

Death Stranding, the highly-anticipated game developed by Hideo Kojima, was praised and criticized in equal measure upon its release in 2019. This article delves into the reasons behind the game's polarizing reception, focusing on its gameplay mechanics, narrative style, pacing, and artistic choices. By understanding these factors, we can better comprehend why critics and players have divergent opinions about the game.

Gameplay Mechanics

The core gameplay of Death Stranding revolves around delivering packages across a vast, post-apocalyptic landscape. Kojima emphasizes traversal and resource management, techniques that can be both highly engaging and tedious, depending on the player's perspective. For some, the game offers a meditative and innovative experience, where attention to detail and strategic planning are rewarded. However, others find the repetitive nature of delivering packages and managing resources to be monotonous and frustrating.

Narrative Style

The story of Death Stranding is complex and often abstract, reflecting themes of isolation, connection, and the impact of technology on society. These themes are explored through a unique blend of cutscenes and dialogue. Kojima's narrative is celebrated by some for its depth and philosophical undertones, while others find it convoluted and difficult to engage with. The game's storytelling is both a strength and a weakness, as it requires players to invest time and emotional energy that may not be rewarded for everyone.

Pacing and Structure

The game's slow pace and emphasis on exploration can be off-putting for players accustomed to fast-paced action. The absence of frequent action sequences can lead to feelings of boredom and frustration. This deliberate pacing is a key aspect of the game's overall experience, intended to create a sense of belonging and connection between players and the world of Death Stranding. However, this approach may not align with the expectations of players looking for a more traditional, high-octane gaming experience.

Artistic Choices

Kojima's distinctive artistic vision is a significant factor in the game's polarizing reception. The surreal visuals and unique character designs are often praised for their creativity and conceptual depth. However, some players may find these choices to be too unconventional or even alienating, preferring more conventional aesthetics. The game's visual style is both a strength and a challenge, as it requires players to accept and become immersed in a world that is fundamentally different from what they might be used to.

Expectations vs. Reality

As a highly-anticipated title from a renowned creator, expectations for Death Stranding were sky-high. Kojima had established a reputation for innovative and critically acclaimed games, such as the Metal Gear series. This led to a wide range of player expectations, ranging from a traditional action game to a narrative-driven experience. The game's blend of these elements can be seen as a strength by those who value both gameplay and story, but a weakness by those who held a particular expectation that was not met.

Multiplayer Elements

The game's unique asynchronous multiplayer system has been both praised and criticized. Players can leave resources for others, creating a sense of community and cooperation. However, some feel that this system detracts from the single-player experience, which was often seen as the core of the game. The multiplayer features are innovative, but their impact on the overall experience is widely debated.

Conclusion

With its mix of innovative gameplay, complex narrative, and unconventional style, Death Stranding is a game that polarizes critics and players alike. The divide in reviews stems from the game's deliberate design choices—its pacing, narrative depth, and artistic vision. These elements either captivate or frustrate differently based on the player's expectations and preferences. Yet, despite its shortcomings, Death Stranding remains a significant and thought-provoking entry in the gaming world, reflecting the diverse tastes and opinions of players.