Why Do We Look Down on Pop Stars Who Don’t Write Their Own Songs?

Pop stars who master the art of singing and playing their own instrument(s), such as the guitar, resonate deeply with fans and critics alike. Their ability to connect with their audience through original music often garners significant respect in the industry. However, there are countless talented performers whose contributions to the pop world are primarily through performance and vocal talents alone, with minimal involvement in the songwriting process. Are these artists worthy of less respect simply because they haven't written the lyrics and melodies?

Artificial vs. Authentic

Some argue that those who don't write their own songs are nothing more than manufactured products churned out by record labels, focused on appearances and stage performances while sidelining true musical talent. In this view, artists like Elton John, whose primary contribution has been his remarkable vocal range, song interpretation, and musical ability, might not have received the same level of acclaim if he hadn't performed under the guidance of a record label.

However, a common belief is that songwriting gives artists a unique identity, making them stand out in the crowded music industry. Iconic singers like Frank Sinatra and Elvis Presley managed to gain significant respect and staying power without penning their own songs. Their innate charisma and stage presence allowed them to captivate audiences and build a strong fan base.

The Role of Authenticity in Branding

Organic songwriting is a powerful tool for artists to establish a unique brand identity. When artists like Elton John focused on songwriting, it added depth and complexity to his image. However, as the album Heart shifted its focus more on the music and less on songwriting, there was a noticeable dip in its popularity during the early 1980s. This example highlights the importance of maintaining a consistent and evolving brand identity.

While organic songwriting can enhance an artist's brand, it is not the sole path to success. Many artists perform flawlessly without delving into songwriting, showcasing their talents through performance alone. The Beatles, for instance, were masters of both songwriting and performance, but even they recognized the value of outsource collaboration. In today's music industry, some songwriters sell their work to producers, and these producers match the music to performers, securing payment for all involved.

Performer vs. Songwriter: Overlapping Roles

Being a songwriter and being a performer are two distinct but interconnected roles in the music industry. Many musicians, such as Bob Dylan and John Lennon, excel in both domains, creating a rich blend of songwriting and performance. Conversely, there are numerous songwriters who excel in crafting melodies and lyrics but may lack the ability to perform in front of a live audience. These songwriters often collaborate with performers to deliver their work to a wider audience.

Ultimately, the respect or admiration an artist receives should not solely depend on whether they write their own songs or not. It is more about the quality of their performances, the authenticity of their art, and their ability to connect with their audience. The music industry thrives on a diverse range of talents, and all contributors, whether they write, perform, or both, play a crucial role in shaping the landscape of music.