Why Do People Criticize BTS's 'BE' Album So Much?

While I personally believe that the 'BE' album by BTS is outstanding, a significant number of fans often compare it unfavorably to their previous works. This article explores why the criticisms of their latest album persist, and whether these concerns are warranted.

Deprecating Past Work

One of the main reasons people criticize the 'BE' album is the frequent statement from fans who say, "Their old music was so much better," and "Their lyrics used to be so meaningful and relatable." It's important to note that the lyrics have not become meaningless; rather, they have evolved. Early BTS lyrics were relatable because they resonated with the teenage experiences of both the artists and their fans. As they have matured, so too have their musical explorations. The 'BE' album delves into topics such as fame and the challenges that come with it, which are universal themes that fans can still relate to.

Lyrical Maturity

Many believe that the lyrics in 'BE' are less meaningful compared to older works. A quick review of annotations on Genius shows that fans and analysts have still found plenty of depth and relevance. Songs like 'Interlude: Shadow' are relatable to everyone, as everyone has their own 'shadow,' regardless of fame. Moreover, the inclusion of more philosophical and introspective content is a natural progression in their artistic journey. While Yoongi's personal experience as a famous individual may not be directly relatable to every fan, the underlying message and emotional truth within the songs remain powerful.

Clarity in Lyrics

Another aspect that contributes to the criticism is the perceived straightforwardness of the album's lyrics. Unlike some of their earlier works, which often contained complex metaphors and deeper meanings, the lyrics in 'BE' are more accessible and straightforward. This stark contrast can be disorienting for long-time fans who are accustomed to spending hours deciphering subtle meanings. However, this should not diminish the quality or authenticity of the songs. Instead, it highlights the growth in BTS's lyrical capabilities and their ability to connect with listeners through more direct and universal themes. Each album from BTS serves a different purpose and appeals to fans in different ways.

It's important to remember that music criticism is subjective. Some fans may prefer the more metaphorical and complex songs from earlier albums, while others are drawn to the simplicity and emotional honesty of 'BE.' Both interpretations are valid, but it's unfair to devalue a recent release simply because it doesn't meet the standards of older works. Music evolves with artists, and dismissing their new work without understanding its context can be a disservice to both the artists and the listeners.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the criticisms of BTS's 'BE' album stem from a combination of nostalgia and the natural evolution of their artistic expression. While it's understandable to miss the complexity of earlier works, it's also crucial to appreciate the growth and authenticity present in 'BE.' As fans, we should embrace the diversity in BTS's output and celebrate the fact that they consistently challenge themselves to explore new themes and emotions through their music.