Why Do Fandoms Become So Toxic? Insights from Undertale and Eddsworld
Fandom toxicity can arise from several factors and while not every fan community becomes toxic, certain dynamics can lead to negative behaviors. Here are some reasons why fandoms like Undertale or Eddsworld may experience toxicity:
Passionate Engagement
Fans often feel deeply connected to the media they love, leading to strong emotional reactions. This passion can sometimes manifest as hostility towards differing opinions or interpretations. The more dedicated and invested a fan is, the more likely they are to perceive any criticism or differing views as a personal attack.
Gatekeeping
Some fans may attempt to define what it means to be a true fan, often resulting in exclusivity and elitism. This gatekeeping behavior can create a sense of alienation among those who may not fit the community's exacting standards, leading to exclusion and hostility.
Conflict Over Canon
When it comes to fan theories, interpretations of character relationships, and storylines, disagreements can lead to heated arguments. For instance, fans of Undertale or Eddsworld might clash over character relationships or plot developments, which can escalate into toxic debates.
The Anonymity of the Internet
Online platforms can embolden individuals to express themselves in ways they might not do in person, leading to harsher criticisms or bullying. The anonymity provided by the internet facilitates behaviors that might be considered inappropriate in a face-to-face environment, creating a breeding ground for toxicity.
Echo Chambers
Social media algorithms can create environments where fans only interact with like-minded individuals, reinforcing negative behaviors and attitudes. This can lead to a cycle of negativity where hostile and toxic comments are given more visibility, creating a self-perpetuating cycle of toxicity.
Cultural Issues
Broader societal issues such as discrimination and harassment can seep into fandoms, leading to toxic behavior that reflects these problems. When these issues are not addressed, they can fester and become more prevalent within the fandom.
Misinformation and Misunderstanding
Misinterpretations of a work or its themes can lead to backlash against creators or other fans, especially if those misunderstandings are widespread. This can create a hostile and unproductive environment where fans are quick to react negatively, even when such reactions may be unwarranted.
Addressing Toxocity Within Fandoms
Addressing toxicity within fandoms often requires open dialogue, empathy, and a commitment to inclusivity. Fostering positive community norms can help mitigate these issues and create a healthier environment for fans. Encouraging constructive criticism, promoting respectful communication, and recognizing and acknowledging the harm caused by toxic behavior are crucial steps toward creating a more inclusive and positive community.
The reason why it is considered toxic is because there are a lot of people in the fandom who like to stalk or harass the IRL (in real life) people. I personally think the fandom’s problems come from the people who think the characters are IRL people. This is a crucial issue that must be addressed to ensure that the community remains safe and welcoming for all members.
It's important to remember that the fandom environment should be a place of enjoyment and creativity for all, and that addressing these issues is a shared responsibility of all community members.