Why Bob Geldof’s Decision to Have Boomtown Rats Perform at Live Aid Was Not About Ruining Credibility

Introduction

There have been numerous debates around the decision of Bob Geldof to have Boomtown Rats perform at Live Aid in 1985. Critics often argue that his insistence on having his band play the event undermined his own credibility. However, examining the context surrounding the decision clarifies that such concerns were unwarranted.

The Context of Live Aid

Live Aid was a global concert event that took place in 1985, organized to raise funds for famine relief in Ethiopia. It was a monumental event, bringing together a diverse collection of performers from across the globe. Bob Geldof was a key figure in organizing this event, and his decision to include Boomtown Rats completed the lineup.

Bob Geldof’s Credibility and the Event

It is important to note that Bob Geldof was already a prominent figure in the music industry by the time Live Aid took place. He had achieved significant fame and recognition, and his influence was evident in his ability to bring together such a grand coalition of musicians for the benefit of a noble cause. Moreover, Geldof had not only reached almost saint-like status at the time, but he also had as much credibility as anyone could desire.

Reasons for the Performance

The argument that Geldof's insistence on Boomtown Rats performing at Live Aid ruined his credibility is rooted in a misunderstanding of the context. Geldof was under no obligation to include his band; it was his choice. He believed that if he was expecting other bands to support the cause, his own band should be willing to do the same. This gesture was not about diminishing his credibility but about setting a positive example.

Moreover, considering the band's status in 1985, they were already has-beens. Therefore, there was no reason to question their influence or their ability to contribute meaningfully to the event. Including them early in the show also allowed Geldof to keep control, as he could maintain his focus on managing the larger aspect of the event without being distracted by the performance of his own band.

Support for the Decision

Much like George Harrison and Ravi Shankar, Robin Williams, Billy Crystal, and Whoopi Goldberg at "Comic Relief," and the members of Monty Python at the various "Policemen’s Balls," Bob Geldof and Boomtown Rats were also supportive of their cause. Not questioning their participation aligns with the spirit of the event. Geldof's decision to include his band was an integral part of the event's success, not a hindrance to it.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the decision to have Boomtown Rats perform at Live Aid was a strategic and contextual move, rather than an act that diminished Bob Geldof's credibility. Geldof's choice illustrated his dedication to the cause and his willingness to put his own band in service of a greater good. The success of Live Aid relied on the collective efforts of all its participants, and Geldof's inclusion of his band was a part of that.

For more information on this topic or to pose questions directly to Bob Geldof, you can reach him in Kent, England.