Why Blackpink Reigns Over Twice: A Cultural and Fan Perspective

Blackpink and Twice, two of the most prominent K-pop girl groups, have captured the hearts of fans worldwide, particularly among teenagers. As a new fan from the UK, I must confess that while TWICE has a certain charm and fanbase, BLACKPINK often steals the spotlight. This article delves into the reasons behind this phenomenon, examining the cultural differences, fan bases, and musical styles of both groups.

Visual Appeal and Magnetic Persona

BLACKPINK has a unique appeal that resonates with a global audience. Their provocative and powerful stage presence, combined with their dynamic visuals, makes them stand out in the K-pop industry. Their concept, often described as badass and edgy, aligns with a contemporary and international fanbase. On the other hand, TWICE exudes a more traditional and contemporary appeal, often embodying a more bubblegum and милый (cute) image. This bubblegum concept is particularly favored in Korea, explaining why TWICE is more recognized within the Asian market, especially in places like Korea, Japan, and Taiwan.

Relatability and Storytelling Through Music

TWICE has a broader appeal among older and younger fans due to their versatile music and storytelling abilities. From their debut with a bubblegum concept to their varied and evolving concepts, TWICE consistently constructs narratives that resonate with their audience. Each of their comeback stories, from A#__M#__O (a play on 'adamu' or 'bromance') to their Halloween and zombie themes, tells a part of the larger story of a girl's journey. Their music is often relatable and easy to sing along to, making it a favorite among fans of all ages.

In contrast, BLACKPINK often employs a more direct and often edgy concept. While they have their own series of relatable songs, their music frequently features profanity without much context, which might not cater to a younger or more traditional fanbase. Their music and concepts, though often praised for their independence and self-love, may not align as closely with the goals or expectations of an average pre-teen or teen fan.

Fandom Engagement and Humility

The TWICE fandom is known to be less toxic, largely because of the group's integrity and genuine engagement with their fans. Members of TWICE are often seen performing small miracles for their fans, such as from a staff member who once mentioned helping TWICE catch a flight in the middle of a city. The group’s humility, kindness, and down-to-earth nature are often highlighted by their fans, making them a fan favorite.

However, this does not imply that the BLACKPINK fandom is toxic. Instead, it simply highlights a different dynamic between the groups. BLACKPINK also has a dedicated and passionate fanbase that admires the group's professionalism and fearless approach to the industry.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the preference for BLACKPINK or TWICE is highly subjective and may vary based on individual taste and cultural background. While BLACKPINK's international appeal and diverse concepts draw a global audience, TWICE retains a strong fanbase in Asia, particularly in Korea, with their bubblegum concept and relatable music. Both groups are incredible in their own right, and the choice comes down to personal preferences and cultural connections.

Both BLACKPINK and TWICE have made significant contributions to the K-pop industry, and it is intriguing to see how their cultural and fan dynamics continue to evolve.