Why Are Indian TV Serials So Predictable?

Indian television serials, popularly known as 'soaps' or 'dramas,' have been a staple of Indian entertainment for decades. However, one common criticism often leveled against these shows is their predictability. It's a notion that often overshadows the intricate storytelling and character development that can be present in these serials. Let's delve into why some viewers find Indian TV serials so predictable and explore the cultural factors that drive this phenomenon.

The Case for Drama and Conflict: Bahu

At the heart of many Indian TV serials is the 'bahu' or daughter-in-law drama. In these narratives, there are often two 'bahus' or daughter-in-laws who compete for the favor of their husband and the in-laws. These rivals engage in constant power plays, deceit, and exposure attempts in a never-ending cycle that can sometimes seem repetitive.

For example, consider a scenario where 'X' and 'Y' are the two bahus. 'X' might concoct a plan to eliminate 'Y' and assert her dominance, but 'Y' is portrayed as wise and resourceful, managing to outsmart and expose 'X' in almost every episode. This predictable pattern can make Indian TV serials feel like a 'guess the next move' game.

Comfort Zones and Predictability

One major reason for the predictability of Indian TV serials is their ability to provide a sense of stability in an often chaotic and dynamic world. Viewers find comfort in the familiar storylines and character archetypes. For instance, the 'saas-bahu' or mother-in-law-daughter-in-law drama is a formula that is deeply rooted in Indian culture, reflecting family dynamics and societal expectations.

To maintain this sense of comfort, writers often avoid drastic changes in the storyline. This can be seen in the reactions of viewers: when their favorite character suffers, it triggers strong emotions such as empathy or outrage. However, if the story veers too far from the norm, it risks alienating the audience. Thus, keeping things predictable ensures that viewers remain engaged over the long term.

Preparing the Grounds for Predictability

Another reason for the predictability of Indian TV serials is the formulaic nature of the storytelling. Writers often rely on established tropes and narratives that have proven successful in the past. This predictability is also reinforced by the repetitive nature of the plots, which can sometimes feel like they're on autopilot.

For example, a common phrase used in these dramas is "bhai aaj tu hoja, kal mein ho jaunga" which translates to "brother, you'll get caught today, tomorrow will be my turn." This mantra is frequently heard, indicating a never-ending cycle of intrigue and exposure, which adds to the predictability.

Stability in a Changing World

The predictability of Indian TV serials can be seen as a reflection of the viewers' desire for stability in their daily lives. In a world that can be uncertain and unpredictable, watching a show that follows a set pattern can provide a sense of comfort and familiarity.

Moreover, these serials often tackle socio-cultural issues, such as family dynamics, traditional values, and societal expectations. By revisiting and reinforcing these issues in each episode, writers ensure that the show remains relevant and relatable to their audience.

However, it's important to note that not all predictability is negative. In many cases, the repetition of storylines and character archetypes can also serve to deepen the viewer's engagement and emotional investment. The familiar elements allow viewers to better connect with the characters and become invested in their personal arcs.

Conclusion

Indian TV serials, with their inherent predictability, cater to a specific demographic that seeks comfort and familiarity in their entertainment. While this predictability can sometimes make the shows feel monotonous to critics, it also ensures that they remain entertaining and engaging for millions of viewers across India and the diaspora.

As audiences continue to evolve, it will be interesting to see how writers navigate the fine line between predictability and innovation, ensuring that these beloved shows remain relevant and captivating for generations to come.