Why Are Critics So Mean? Unpacking the Role and Impact of Critics in the Arts

In the realms of film, theater, and literature, critics often play a pivotal role in shaping public perception and artistic evolution. However, the relationship between artists and critics can sometimes be contentious, with artists frequently questioning the validity and intentions behind critical evaluations.

The Role of Critics

Critics serve as filters for the market, helping to differentiate between groundbreaking works and those that may fall short. They are, almost without exception, individuals who have chosen to focus their careers on offering nuanced and informed critiques of the arts. Some artists may resent these critics, believing that they thwart their artistic vision. But is this resentment justified, or is it simply a result of a mutual lack of understanding about the role of the critic?

Offering Constructive Criticism

Critics should aim to offer constructive feedback rather than simply tearing apart a work. When a critic expresses dissatisfaction, it is important that this critique is rooted in the actual work that has been produced, rather than their personal desires or imagined alternatives. For instance, if a filmmaker has chosen to explore certain themes and narratives, a fair criticism would be to comment on whether these elements were effectively executed, rather than expressing disappointment at a movie that did not align with the critic's personal preferences. Critics should be analysts of the art that is in front of them, not dreamers of what could have been.

The Duality of Being a Critic

Very few people begin their academic or professional journeys with the intention of becoming critics. Many enter film or theater programs in college with the ambition to become actors or directors, only later discovering a talent for and passion in critique. It is interesting to note that the path to becoming a professional critic is often unconventional.

Decisive moments can often lead to unexpected career paths. In a critique environment, students or budding artists may be asked to write reviews for class assignments, with their writing skills and sharp observations catching the eye of those in the industry. A piece that showcases their talent and verve can then be published, and before long, these individuals find themselves working as critics, often compensated generously for their work. However, a shockingly high number of these critics eventually find themselves despised, not only by those whose works they critique but also by those who despise them just as much.

Challenges and Realities

Critics face numerous challenges. One challenge is the constant desire for praise. Just like every human, critics can become complacent and arrogant when their opinions are widely sought after. Another challenge is the need for objectivity, which can be difficult in a field where strong personal opinions and biases can influence judgments. Critics are not immune to the pressures of the market or the need to please those who fund their work, which can sometimes lead to questionable standards of objectivity.

Resilience and Self-Belief

The key to surviving in such a contentious environment is resilience and self-belief. If you believe that your critiques are valuable and necessary, then you must stand firm in your convictions. Art is subjective, and while some critiques may resonate more than others, the importance of offering feedback should not be undermined. It is ultimately the responsibility of the critic to improve the discourse and help artists refine their craft. Artist and critic alike must understand that criticism is a two-way street; both parties are working towards better understanding and appreciation of the art form.

Conclusion: The relationship between artists and critics is complex and multifaceted. While it can sometimes be fraught with tension, the role of critics is crucial in shaping the evolution of art. By offering honest, constructive criticism, critics play a vital role in helping artists improve and in fostering a deeper appreciation of the arts.