Whose Books Are Better: J.K. Rowling or Rick Riordan?
When it comes to choosing between J.K. Rowling and Rick Riordan, it's complicated. While Rowling may be the author of a globally recognized and best-selling series, Rick Riordan has carved his own niche with equally compelling stories. Let's delve into why Rick Riordan might be considered a better writer, but not without acknowledging the significant contributions of Rowling.
Popularity
Rowling wins the popularity contest hands down. Her books have reached a vast audience, far surpassing even the epic success of Rick Riordan's works. The Harry Potter series has sold over 500 million copies and has undoubtedly made a substantial cultural impact. Similarly, Percy Jackson the Olympians series has sold nearly 100 million copies worldwide. Despite his remarkable success, Riordan's universes have not quite achieved the same level of reach and cultural significance.
World Building
When it comes to world building, both writers have their strengths. However, a personal bias leans towards Rick Riordan. The Percy Jackson universe and its interconnected plots drew me in from the very first page, offering a unique and engaging experience. The folklore and mythological elements combined with the relatable characters and their relationships make for a compelling narrative. Conversely, the Harry Potter series is well-known for its meticulously crafted magical world, but the relationships within it are more structured and less dynamic.
Natural Inclusivity
Rick Riordan stands out in terms of natural inclusivity. His characters are authentic and well-integrated. For instance, the LGBTQ and POC characters in his works are integral to the stories, making a real impact. Nico's journey in falling in love with Percy is a poignant, believable arc. Alex Fierro's gender fluidity is not merely a plot device but a core aspect of the story, adding depth and realism. Similarly, Samirah Al Abbas' faith is explored with sensitivity and care. Compare this to Rowling’s attempts to retroactively include diversity, often falling short. Hermione's race was initially unspecified, and she struggled to fit into a predominantly white narrative framework.
Character Development
Winner: Rick Riordan. The Harry Potter characters, while certainly evolving, remain largely static and unchanged by the events of the series. They maintain their core traits and beliefs, which, while consistent, lack depth and complexity. In contrast, Riordan’s characters undergo significant and meaningful transformations. Nico's journey toward self-acceptance is a standout example. Leo, the self-proclaimed "seventh wheel," grows into a character of great importance and emotional depth. These arcs are not just superficial changes but meaningful character development.
Conclusion
While J.K. Rowling's contributions to the realm of fantasy literature are immeasurable, Rick Riordan stands out for his skill in world building, natural inclusivity, and character development. His Percy Jackson series offers a compelling blend of mythology and contemporary themes, making it a worthy contender in the world of children's and young adult literature.