Who is the Better Actor: Amitabh Bachchan or Mammooty?
The question of whether Amitabh Bachchan or Mammooty is the better actor is a heated debate among movie enthusiasts and critics alike. While Mammooty is undoubtedly a very good actor, his prowess is more confined to the south of India. On the other hand, Amitabh Bachchan's appeal transcends geographical boundaries, earning him a global fan following.
Amitabh Bachchan: A Global Icon
Amitabh Bachchan is not comparable to any actor in his league. He is a legend and a global superstar. His baritone voice and on-screen presence make him a magnetic figure. Bachchan became a super star at the age of 35 and went on to become the 'Shehed of Bollywood'. Known for his powerful and unique baritone voice, Bachchan has also sung over 30 songs in his career. He has not only acted in films but also ventured into business, hosting major events such as the Miss World in 1996. His name is also registered in the Guiness Book of World Records for singing the Hanuman Chalisa.
Bachchan has also hosted shows like Kaun Banega Crorepati since 2000, and he bid farewell to the show in December 2023. His ability to take on diverse roles and connect with audiences from different backgrounds has made him a global icon.
Mohanlal: A Versatile and Dogged Actor
Mohanlal, a fan favorite from Kerala, has been a consistent and versatile actor from a very young age. His journey began in the 1970s, and his breakthrough came with his role in Manjil Virinja Pookkal in 1982. His character, Narendran, captured the audience's attention due to his unique mannerisms.
Mohanlal's career witnessed a significant milestone in 1986 when he acted in over 30 films, with 80% being successful. This included movies like Rajavinte Makan and Sanmanassulavarkku Samadhanam, which solidified his position as a versatile and bankable star. Collaborations with renowned directors such as Padmarajan, Sathyan Anthikkadu, Thampy Kannanthanam, and Hariharan further enhanced his reputation.
Mohanlal's versatility as an actor is evident from his ability to tackle various genres. From romantic films like Nadodikattu to thrillers like Kamaladalam Veenaprastham, and musical hits like Abdul Bhareyath, he has demonstrated his talent in a myriad of roles. His performances in films such as Puli Murugan showcase his dedication and passion, even in more challenging roles.
Comparison: National Award 2006
A fascinating comparison can be found in their portrayals in the National Award-winning films 'Black' and 'Thanmathra' in 2006. Despite Amitabh Bachchan winning the National Award, many critics feel that Mohanlal's performance in 'Thanmathra' was more natural and commendable. Mohanlal's ability to bring depth and authenticity to his roles, especially in a film like Manjil Virinja Pookkal, cannot be overlooked.
While North Indian viewers may favor Bachchan's global influence and fame, someone like the author, who has watched over 90 films featuring both actors, firmly believes in Mohanlal's superiority. His consistent performances and ability to command diverse roles make him a more holistic and respected actor in the industry.
Conclusion
Both Amitabh Bachchan and Mohanlal are outstanding actors, each with their unique strengths and legacies. Amitabh Bachchan's global influence and versatility have made him a legend, while Mohanlal's consistent excellence and versatility have solidified his status as a true auteur in the film industry.