Was Snape Really Concerned About Harry?

Severus Snape's feelings towards Harry Potter are a complex subject of debate, especially considering the conflicting nature of his actions. At first glance, it may seem that Snape is protective of the boy who lived, but a closer examination of his motivations reveals a more nuanced perspective. Was Snape's concern for Harry genuine, or was it driven by guilt and the memory of Lily Potter?

Protective Instincts

Snape frequently displayed protective instincts towards Harry, often acting to safeguard him from impending danger, often without Harry's knowledge. However, this behavior seems partly influenced by his love for Harry's mother, Lily. For instance, Snape would warn Harry during Quidditch matches and intervene during critical moments, showing that his concern for Harry is rooted in his love for Lily.

Resentment and Conflict

Snape's animosity towards Harry is deeply interconnected with his bitter memories of James Potter, who was Lily's husband. Snape despised James and this hatred extended even after James' death. Snape continued to speak ill of James, reflecting poorly on him and disregarding his true character, a view that was rooted in jealousy and resentment. The hatred for James resurfaced when Snape saw Harry as a reminder of James, casting a shadow over his actions. This conflict between protective instincts and personal feelings of anger and resentment offers a clear picture of Snape's complex emotions.

Final Revelations

The truth about Snape's feelings came to light during a pivotal conversation with Albus Dumbledore. During a serious discussion, Dumbledore asked if Snape had grown to care for Harry. Snape's response with a spell and the release of his patronus, the silver doe, coupled with Dumbledore's tears, revealed profound emotions. However, Snape's statement, "For her," during the conversation, aligns with his affection for Lily, not Harry.

Snape's actions towards Harry were largely driven by guilt over Lily's death, which he found himself partially responsible for. His treatment of Harry was marked by a deep-seated resentment towards James, and he viewed Harry as a young version of his hated rival. For example, Snape's dismissive comments about Harry's capabilities and the way he treated him were indicative of his personal biases and hatred towards James, not any genuine care for Harry.

The Resurface of Resentment

Snape's hatred for James so transcended his time that even in death, James' depiction in Snape's mind remained firmly negative. Snape's actions towards Harry revolved around a deep-seated resentment that Harry was reminiscent of James, and this resentment clouded his judgment, making him unaware that Harry was not his father and should not be treated with the same level of disdain.

A truly heartfelt moment comes when Snape declared, "But this is touching, Severus." "Have you grown to care for the boy after all?""For her," shouted Snape. "Expecto Patronum!" The burst of the silver doe and Dumbledore's tears underscore the depth of Snape's affection for Lily, highlighting that his care and concern were not for Harry, but for his late wife.

These revelations encapsulate a complex interplay of love, guilt, and resentment. Snape's actions towards Harry were heavily influenced by his past and his feelings for Lily, making it clear that his care for Harry was more hypothetical and less genuine than it appeared.

Key Points:

Protection Rooted in Love: Snape's actions were often driven by his love for Lily. Resentment Renewed: Harry reminded Snape of James, reigniting his hatred and resentment. Guilt and Shame: Snape felt guilty over Lily's death and partially blamed himself. Manipulation by Dumbledore: Dumbledore's influence may have shaped Snape's feelings and actions.

In conclusion, while Snape's behavior towards Harry may have appeared caring, it was ultimately driven by deep-seated resentment towards James and a fervent love for Lily. The true source of Snape's concern lies with Lily, not Harry, as demonstrated by his final revelations and Dumbledore's understanding of Snape's affections.