What Would Albus Dumbledore or Aberforth Have Made of Children in Their World?
Recently, I came across a fascinating discussion about the possibility of Albus Dumbledore or his brother Aberforth having children in the Harry Potter universe. While there is no definitive answer, let's explore how this hypothetical scenario could play out. If Albus Dumbledore, the esteemed headmaster of Hogwarts, had a child with someone, whether it was with his brother Aberforth or another individual, the consequences and dynamics could be quite interesting. Here are a few potential scenarios:
Potential Scenarios
First Version: Classic Gay Family TV Show
If Albus Dumbledore and Aberforth had a child, the early 21st-century cultural adaptation would likely feature these two in a classic gay family TV show. Grindelwald, who was fiercely devoted to his ambitions, would experience a profound shift in his life upon realizing what true love means. This realisation could lead to a dramatic break from his previous plans, and he might abandon his quest for dominance.
Dumbledore, meanwhile, might move into Grindelwald's home, leading to a tight-knit and supportive family dynamic. The two brothers could take care of each other, perhaps even sharing traditional family holidays. This might lead to rather embarrassed and comedic interactions, like:
“Be careful what you tell to your grandma Arianna; she’s very old, don’t upset her!”
On a more practical note, Aberforth could take care of the family while Dumbledore and Grindelwald might support them financially and emotionally.
Second Version: A Breakup and Period of Turmoil
In another scenario, the relationship between Dumbledore and Grindelwald could result in a breakup. If Grindelwald discovered Dumbledore's pregnancy after the fact, the relationship could crumble, leading to a storyline reminiscent of Bellatrix and Dark Lord Voldemort. This would likely result in tension, betrayal, and potentially gruesome events.
Third Version: Altruism and Power Plays
If Dumbledore's pregnancy were to occur, it might change his perspective significantly. In this version, Grindelwald could use this situation to his advantage, seeking to manipulate Dumbledore's involvement in his plans. This could lead to Dumbledore's assistance in Grindelwald's scheme to dominate the world, ultimately becoming a tragic hero or villain depending on the narrative's bias.
Fourth Version: A Halloween Version
The scenario could also take a darker, more mysterious turn. Grindelwald might keep the pregnancy a secret and control the situation, creating a tense and suspenseful atmosphere reminiscent of horror stories. Strange occurrences and eerie sounds might be heard in the attic or basement. Children might uncover dark secrets they never should have known.
My Opinion
In considering the hypothetical scenario where Aberforth, known for his affection for goats, and Albus, who had to kill his first real love, might pass on their genetic material, it becomes a matter of probability and character development. Given Aberforth's deep connection to goats and Albus's tragic past, it would be highly unlikely that either of them would raise a child successfully without facing immense emotional and personal challenges.
However, if such a union were to occur, it would likely create a compelling subplot in a Harry Potter fan novel. This scenario could draw similarities to more fantastical and dark stories, such as the events leading up to and following the birth of The Cursed Child — the one time Albus got drunk and woke up next to a witch instead of a wizard — or when Aberforth met a woman so enchanting that he forgot about his goats.
Ultimately, the idea of Albus or Aberforth having children in the Harry Potter universe holds tremendous potential, adding depth and complexity to their characters.