Was the Wicked Witch of the West an Innocent Victim?

The Wicked Witch of the West, often portrayed as a malevolent character in The Wizard of Oz, raises the intriguing question: Could she have been an innocent victim at all? By delving into the prequel universe, we explore the intricacies of her character and the events that transpired before her infamous transformation.

The Prequel Universe

When considering a more expansive narrative surrounding the events of The Wizard of Oz, the prequel films or books set before Dorothy’s arrival offer a new perspective on the Wicked Witch of the West. In these stories, she is known as Theodora, a sister of the powerful and manipulative Evanora.

The Transformation of Theodora

Theodora, a well-meaning and kind-hearted individual, is ultimately corrupted by her older sibling Evanora. The transforming factor in this manipulation is a magic apple presented to Theodora as a ruse. Undeterred by the potential consequences, Theodora obeys Evanora’s nefarious plan and bites the apple, transforming her into the fiendish Green Witch. This transformation is not only physical but also psychological, drastically altering Theodora’s character.

Blame and Legal Perspective

The legal standpoint regarding the blame placed on Dorothy seems rather complex. In the world of Oz, there is no mention of organized legal systems such as courts or lawyers, suggesting a different approach to conflict resolution. The Ozian law likely held a unique understanding, placing responsibility more directly on individuals or acts that could be controlled.

The Premises of Ozian Law

For any grievance against Dorothy to hold legal weight, it must have involved intentional action. Dorothy’s house landing on the Wicked Witch of the West was a matter of fate, not malice. In insurance terms, this situation would be considered an act of God, or an event beyond human control. Consequently, such an event cannot be held liable or penalized legally.

The Role of Evanora

Evanora, Theodora’s manipulative sister, played a significant role in her transformation and subsequent actions. Her encouragement of Theodora's temper and emotional manipulation likely contributed to Theodora’s decision to bite the apple. This transformation and the subsequent actions should be viewed more as a result of manipulation and less as an independent choice by Theodora.

Conclusion: No Legal Grounds for Complaint

Given the unique characteristics of the Ozian society, it is highly unlikely that Theodora (Wicked Witch of the West) would have a valid case against Dorothy. Both Evanora and the Wicked Witch were public enemies to Oz, causing terror and hardship. Theodora’s actions, though monstrous, were the result of manipulation, not free will. Therefore, under Ozian law, even if Theodora tried to bring her case to the Emerald City, there would be no legal grounds to support her claim.

Interesting indeed that we can explore the narrative in such detail, delving not just into the characters but also into the world and legal framework of Oz.

Thanks for reading my post.

Ereil Novaborne