Viserys I Targaryen vs. Robert Baratheon: A Comparative Analysis of their Small Councils

The Game of Thrones TV series, while not strictly adhering to every detail of George R.R. Martin’s books, provides a rich canvas for political intrigue and power struggles. The small council, or the small sept, as it is sometimes referred to in the context of Westeros, plays a pivotal role in the governance of the Seven Kingdoms. This article explores a comparison between the small councils of Viserys I Targaryen and Robert Baratheon, two significant kings of Westeros. We aim to analyze the makeup of their councils and the impact of their advisors on their respective reigns.

Introduction

The small council of a Westerosi king is a group of trusted advisors who offer counsel on various aspects of governance, including politics, diplomacy, and military strategy. This council, also mentioned as the small sept, is an essential part of the narrative in both the books and the TV series.
In this comparison, we will delve into the small councils of Viserys I Targaryen and Robert Baratheon, discussing their strengths and weaknesses. While the show’s decline may have scrambled some memories, we will still try to uncover valuable insights into these two important monarchs and their administrations.

Viserys I Targaryen's Small Council

Viserys I Targaryen, or Viserys the Victorious, ascended the Iron Throne after his father, Aegon IV Targaryen, in 114AC (Aegon Century). His reign was relatively stable, but his small council, while not exceedingly influential, played a significant role in maintaining the stability of the Targaryen kingdom. Here is an analysis of the members of his small council:

1. Grand Maester Pycelle

Grand Maester Pycelle was Viserys I’s primary advisor. Known for his wisdom and knowledge of the Seven, Pycelle was a Maester of the Citadel and held the position of Grand Maester, which made him a prominent figure in the small council. His role was to provide counsel on matters of diplomacy, law, and governance. However, his loyalty to the crown sometimes led to potential conflicts, particularly during Robert’s Rebellion, as he was perceived as a supporter of the monarchy.

2. Alyn Peake and Ser Preston Greenfield

Alyn Peake and Ser Preston Greenfield were soldiers who held important positions in the king’s council. Alyn Peake served as Hand of the King, which offered him significant influence over the king’s decisions. Ser Preston Greenfield, a master at arms, was responsible for the safety and security of the realm. These military advisors were crucial during the various military campaigns of Viserys I’s reign.

Robert Baratheon's Small Council

Robert Baratheon, a commoner who rose to power and became the king in 283AC, had a small council that closely reflected his pragmatic approach to governance. His council, which comprised members of the new ruling Baratheon family and their allies, was instrumental in shaping the political landscape of the Seven Kingdoms. Here is an analysis of the members of his small council:

1. Lord Stannis Baratheon

Stannis Baratheon, Robert’s older brother, was a key figure in the small council. As the Lord of Storm’s End, Stannis was a respected figure and a skilled military leader. His influence extended beyond his military expertise; he was also well-versed in matters of law and governance. Despite his support for his brother, Stannis often had ideological conflicts with Robert, especially regarding the idea of protecting non-noble families.

2. Lord Renly Baratheon

Renly Baratheon, Robert’s younger brother and a skilled diplomat, served as Lord of Highgarden. Renly was known for his charm, charisma, and his diplomatic skills. His role in the small council was to handle relations with other noble families, ensuring alliances and loyalty. Renly’s influence within the council was significant, particularly in maintaining the support of the Tyrells.

3. Varys

Though HBO’s TV series often conflated characters for drama, Varys was a secret advisor and intelligence-gathering mastermind in the court of Robert Baratheon. Despite his secrecy, his influence on the outcome of the war against the Lannisters was significant. Varys’ role was to provide Robert with information on his enemies, aiding in the planning of military and political strategies.

A Comparative Analysis

The small councils of Viserys I Targaryen and Robert Baratheon had distinct characteristics, reflecting the different approaches each king took to governance. Viserys I’s council, with its emphasis on traditional stability and Maester’s wisdom, reflected a more conservative and cautious approach. On the other hand, Robert Baratheon’s council, with its emphasis on new alliances and brotherly support, showed a more pragmatic and ambitious agenda.

Both councils played crucial roles in the governance of their respective reigns. However, the dynamic and makeup of each council differed significantly. Viserys I relied heavily on the experience and wisdom of his advisors, while Robert Baratheon’s council was more diverse, reflecting the new Baratheon family’s ambitions and the need to consolidate power.

Conclusion

The small councils of Viserys I Targaryen and Robert Baratheon provide valuable insights into the governance of Westeros. While both councils were essential for the maintenance of power during their reigns, their compositions and dynamics illustrate the different challenges and approaches faced by these kings. Understanding the roles and contributions of each advisor in these councils can deepen our appreciation of the complex political landscape of Game of Thrones.