Unveiling the Vocal Landscape: Differences Between Opera Stars and Chorus Members

Are opera stars significantly different from regular chorus members? It is a nuanced question with many layers, influenced by a mix of talent, experience, and personal choices. To understand this distinction better, we must explore the backgrounds, roles, and reasons behind these singers' career paths.

Age-Related Standouts

While any exceptional voice can be found in a chorus, standout vocalists are often identified during high school and early undergraduate years. By the time a singer exceeds 25, their chances of being part of a chorus rather than pursuing a soloist career become slimmer. However, this isn't always the case.

The Divisive Path of Choristers

There are various reasons why seasoned singers opt for chorus roles over soloist careers. Some of these reasons include:

Steady Employment

One of the primary reasons choristers choose this path is the stability it offers. Chorus positions are often less demanding in terms of travel, making them more suitable for those who need a reliable schedule, such as those with family commitments.

Limited Spotlight

Some choristers do not crave the limelight that comes with being a soloist. The chorus offers a more intimate setting where attention is not as central.

Technique and Education Development

Quite a few chorus members are still refining their technique and furthering their vocal education. Some may even be pursuing their masters or doctorate in voice performance. These individuals typically stay in chorus roles for no more than two or three years, as prolonged membership can detract from their soloist resumes.

Settling for Chorus

Some singers may have already reached their peak in the soloist world and have no aspirations to compete with more established performers. Chorus roles can offer a comfortable fallback.

Hobbies and Passions

Others may have demanding careers outside of singing and use chorus as a hobby, enjoying the experience without seeking the spotlight.

Exposure to Professionalism

Still, some choristers lack the necessary connections, experience, or the star-making presence required for a soloist career.

Post-Solo Career Concessions

Occasionally, singers from a solo career return to the chorus after some time, keeping their skills sharp but often for career diversification or as a haven during transitional periods.

The Politics of Opera Houses

Not all opera houses are created equal. In smaller houses, the choir may consist of skilled but less notable performers. In contrast, renowned opera houses maintain a much higher standard for their choir members. These choirs often consist of professional musicians who are paid well.

Choir as a Path to Success

Chorus members in famous opera houses often strive to break through the ranks to secure soloist roles. However, due to the high demand for famous and reliable singers, aspiring soloists must establish themselves in smaller houses before making a mark in the big houses.

Giulietta Simionato: An Inspiring Case Study

Giulietta Simionato, a renowned mezzo-soprano, is a prominent example of this. She was a member of the La Scala choir well into her 30s, patiently waiting for opportunities. Despite her remarkable talent, she faced the challenge of not advancing, which is a common struggle for many choristers.

However, her perseverance eventually paid off. Recognized for her exceptional abilities, she embarked on an illustrious solo career. This example highlights the potential, even for choristers, to achieve greatness.

Conclusion

While there may be outstanding singers within a chorus, many of the soloists hold distinguishing vocal capabilities and experience. The distinction between opera stars and chorus members is complex, often driven by personal choices, career trajectories, and the political dynamics within specific opera houses.