The Unreasonable Suspicions of Sansa and Arya: A Deeper Look at Their Feuds

Often in the A Song of Ice and Fire series, the characters’ motivations and actions are complex, reflecting a mix of family loyalty, personal vendettas, and the uncertain political landscape. A prime example of this complexity is the relationship between Sansa and Arya Stark and Daenerys Targaryen. This article delves into why Sansa and Arya have such intense suspicions against Daenerys, despite the choices and actions that both parties have taken.

Context and Background

Their suspicion of Daenerys is built on a foundation of family history, the presence of dragons, and the differing views on Northern independence. Daenerys, a member of the same Targaryen line that killed Sansa and Arya’s grandfather and uncle, is seen as an old enemy. Furthermore, her actions in places like Meereen and her claim of dragons add to the mistrust.

The Role of Family Conflict

One of the primary reasons for Sansa and Arya’s mistrust is the long history of family conflict within the Targaryen lineage. They remember the atrocities committed by their ancestors, which resonates deeply with their own experiences. This familial enmity has been passed down through generations, creating a legacy of distrust that is difficult to overcome.

Dragons: A Source of Unnatural Power and Fear

The presence of dragons is another significant factor in their distrust. In the words of Sansa and Arya, "she has fucking dragons," symbolizing an ancient magical threat. Dragons represent a form of power that seems almost mythical and uncontrollable, which naturally instills fear and unease in individuals who are accustomed to more rational or manageable forms of power.

The Issue of Northern Independence

Another critical reason for their mistrust is Daenerys' stance on Northern independence. Following the cruel rule of House Bolton, the North has a strong desire to remain free and independent. Daenerys, however, sees the North as a pawn in her broader political ambitions. This clash of interests is a significant source of tension. When Sansa hears that Daenerys is willing to help the North unconditionally, it appeals to her, but when Daenerys’ true intentions are revealed, it only strengthens her resolve against Daenerys.

Atrocities and Historical Trauma

The historical trauma inflicted by House Targaryen on House Stark is also a contributing factor to Sansa’s and Arya’s suspicions. The past atrocities committed by the Targaryens, especially those against the Stark family, are not easily forgotten. Even when Daenerys offers help without Jon giving up his crown, it is the history of betrayal and violence that makes them wary. They see potential for more of the same.

Personal Trauma and Loss

Both Sansa and Arya have experienced significant personal trauma and loss. The absence of truth, as seen with Jon’s non-disclosure of what happened after Viserion’s death, adds to their suspicion. They fear that the truth might be worse than what they already know, and this further fuels their mistrust. The belief that their loved ones would have been left to die if they had simply submitted also reinforces their resistance to any Targaryen offer of help.

Conclusion: A Calling for Deeper Understanding

The mistrust and suspicion between Sansa and Arya, and Daenerys, are multi-faceted and deeply rooted. The legacy of past trauma, the presence of dragons, and the desire for independence are all significant factors. While Daenerys’ intentions and actions can be debated, the psychological impact of these factors on characters like Sansa and Arya cannot be understated. Understanding these complex dynamics is key to appreciating the rich narrative tapestry of A Song of Ice and Fire.