The Sopranos and Modern Organized Crime: A Closer Look
Is The Sopranos accurate in portraying modern organized crime? To answer this question, let's delve into the factual basis and insights from the FBI during actual investigations. The series, while offering significant entertainment value, presents a mix of accuracy and dramatization. This article explores both the factual elements and the fictional liberties taken, highlighting the opinions and experiences of those familiar with the workings of organized crime.
Accuracy of The Sopranos: From Reality to Drama
The Sopranos has long been praised for its nuanced portrayal of the Italian American Mafia, or La Cosa Nostra. However, opinions vary regarding the series' accuracy. The FBI, during real-life investigations involving actual N.J. Organized Crime members, even discussed the possibility of a rat within the show's crew, based on how accurate the show appeared to be. Listen to the transcripts of wire tap recordings, and you will see their discussions unfold.
For one, the depiction of a boss and his associates is not entirely realistic. A real boss could certainly wear shorts and operate that way, a practice mentioned by real-life gangsters. Furthermore, a boss would not tolerate higher voices or disrespect from his associates. Yelling at the boss or walking out on him would have dire consequences in real life. Consider, also, the role of a psychiatrist in the series—something that would never happen in actual organized crime. The show, while deeply flawed in some aspects, can still be seen as a close reflection of the reality it attempts to portray.
Level of Violence: Fact vs. Fiction
The level of violence in The Sopranos was heavily dramatized for storytelling and entertainment purposes. While exaggerated, the series captures a significant portion of the gritty reality behind organized crime. David Chase, the creator, is widely recognized as a genius for bringing such depth and complexity to the narrative. The show's portrayal of organized crime is akin to that of a Stanley Kubrick film, each episode and season warranting multiple viewings to uncover hidden layers of meaning.
Myths and Realities in the Show
One of the most striking examples of the show's exaggeration is the first episode where a mafia mother pulls out an AK-47 upon suspecting her daughter might be in trouble. In reality, traditional and practical reasons dictate that mafia wives remain separated from their husbands' work. This separation maintaining traditional values and providing deniability against accusations.
Besides, using automatic rifles for home defense is impractical. Shotguns and handguns are preferred due to their legal status and ease of concealment. Similarly, mobsters do not typically engage in unnecessary violence; they prefer to keep such activities low-key, like cleaning toilets or taking out trash, understanding that these tasks need occasional completion.
Character Development and Realities
Christopher Moltisanti's character is perhaps the most debated. The series's portrayal of him as a self-proclaimed enforcer eager to prove himself through violence is unrealistic. In real life, individuals who focus on killing and starting fights would be quickly eliminated. The killing of individuals in organized crime is often a low-level task, and showing dedication to the business by bringing in money is more valued.
Early in the series, Christopher is shown attempting to start a war by killing and threatening others. He would be swiftly dealt with, much like a beloved dog that can't stop attacking. Consider the scene in Goodfellas where Joe Pesci's character is put down, and the phrase "Poor little guy. He was a sweet guy if you knew him he really had it in him. Just couldn’t stop himself" reflects the reality that such a character would be quickly removed to protect the organization.
Conclusion
While The Sopranos contains significant inaccuracies, its portrayal of modern organized crime is not entirely off the mark. The show offers a complex and nuanced view of the Mafia, capturing both the gritty realities and the entertainment value of their activities. As a fan of the series, it is essential to understand the boundaries between fact and fiction, appreciating the drama while acknowledging the real-world complexities of organized crime.