The Role of Vocalists in ITZY: An Analysis of Yuna’s Talents and Challenges
ITZY is a K-pop girl group known for their unique style and vocal prowess, with each member bringing a distinct contribution to their sound. While the group's main vocal Liu Liang (Lia) is acknowledged for her advanced vocal technique and vocal range, a discussion has surrounded why Yuna, who has shown impressive vocal capabilities, hasn't taken on the role of the main vocalist. This article aims to explore the dynamics behind ITZY’s vocal structure and Yuna's vocal abilities, highlighting the unique characteristics of each vocalist and the reasons behind their roles.
An Overview of Yuna's Vocal Capabilities
Yuna, a member of ITZY, has garnered attention for her impressive vocal performances, particularly in cover versions of songs by other groups such as APINK. Her ability to perform high notes without straining her voice has been a focal point of discussion. However, it's important to understand that while Yuna excels in hitting high notes, vocal ability goes beyond note-preservation. The quality of a vocalist is determined by factors such as technique, range, and support or voce correra (breath control and tone quality).
Yuna's talent shines in her ability to hit higher notes, which can be surprising considering her young age. However, this ease in hitting high notes is often attributed to her naturally high and nasally voice, which makes it relatively easier for her to reach higher pitches. Nonetheless, the assertion that Yuna is a good vocalist due to her ability to hit high notes overlooks other critical aspects of singing, such as technique and support.
The Role of Vocal Technique and Support in K-pop
K-pop vocalists are often evaluated based on their ability to support their voice with proper breath control and vocal technique. Lia, ITZY's main vocalist, stands out due to her vocal support and control, enabling her to hit notes like Bb4 without straining. This is a more significant factor than simply hitting high notes. Lia's vocal technique allows her to mix higher than D5 and even reach F5, demonstrating a sophisticated and mature control over her voice.
Yuna, on the other hand, is still developing her vocal technique and support. As a young artist, she is still maturing, and it is not unusual for singers to go through periods of vocal growth and development. While Yuna can hit higher notes, her technique is not as refined as Lia's, which is evident in how she handles her vocal strain. Strain in the voice is a sign of poor technique and can lead to vocal damage if not managed properly.
The Dynamics of Vocal Roles in ITZY
The decision to assign a vocalist the role of main vocalist in a K-pop group is based on a complex interplay of factors including vocal range, style, stage presence, and the overall dynamic of the group. In ITZY, Lia's role as the main vocalist is not merely a matter of vocal superiority; it is also about the group's concept and the sound they want to project.
Each member of ITZY has their unique strengths and roles that contribute to the group's success. While Yuna has shown remarkable vocal capabilities, especially in high notes, the group's concept and the technical requirements of some of their songs necessitate that Lia continues to hold the main vocal role. Moreover, the fluid nature of K-pop groups allows members to showcase their vocal skills in different contexts, such as solo performances or special stages, where they can demonstrate their versatility.
Ultimately, the roles of the vocalists in ITZY are determined by the needs of the group and the overall vision set by the agency. Fans appreciate the diverse talents of all members, and each contributes to the group's success in their own way. The discussions around vocal roles in K-pop groups are often nuanced and multifaceted, reflecting the complex nature of the industry and the unique dynamics within each group.
Conclusion
The debate over who should be the main vocalist in ITZY is a reflection of the complexity and depth of the K-pop industry. While Yuna's vocal abilities are impressive, the dynamics of K-pop vocal groups and the specific needs of ITZY's music lead to the current arrangement. Understanding the technical aspects of singing and the specific requirements of K-pop groups can provide a more nuanced understanding of these complex discussions.