The Risks of Working Alone with Clients: Insights from an Attorney
As a lawyer, have you ever been scared to be alone with your client? The answer is no, never. In my experience, the relationship between a lawyer and their client is built upon trust, informed decisions, and understanding the potential outcomes of legal cases. Whether the case involves criminal or civil matters, my clients are well-aware of the risks and rewards, and I strive to prepare them for all eventualities.
Client Preparation: A Key Priority
The hiring of a lawyer typically brings a sense of relief and security to my clients. They understand the possible outcomes of their cases and are willing to pay for legal representation accordingly. In civil cases, a lawyer can claim 33% of a favorable judgment, and they may opt to charge administrative fees if the case results in a loss.
In a criminal case, having a lawyer present can significantly reduce a sentence, even if a guilty verdict is reached. However, it is crucial to recognize that the absence of honesty from a client can make their legal representation significantly more challenging. Misleading or lying to your lawyer can make it difficult to provide proper legal advice, as it hinders the attorney's ability to understand the client's true situation.
While rare, there have been instances where lawyers have been harmed by clients. However, these cases usually involve clients who are either mentally unstable or diagnosed with specific psychological disorders. For instance, a proven psychopath or a client with severe mental health issues can pose a risk. In all scenarios, proper protections and precautions should be in place to ensure the safety of both the lawyer and the client.
Personal Experiences in Legal Practice
As a petite woman, I have worked in various areas of law, one of which was the workers' compensation field. This practice area often involves individuals who have been injured at work, and it has its unique challenges. Throughout my career, I have encountered clients with various personalities, some of whom exhibited aggressive tendencies, but generally not directed at me directly.
Switching to the insurance side, I have occasionally faced unrepresented claimants who regarded me as the embodiment of the insurance company, often seeking to blame me for their predicaments. Since these claimants provided their medical records, we had a clear understanding of their mental state and potential for aggression.
A few times, a colleague would accompany me to official meetings to provide additional security. One colleague, who had had two hip replacements and was on the verge of needing knee replacements, acted as a form of protection. Although no incidents arose, it was a question of whether I, as a woman, would have needed protection from the claimants.
Truly, my encounters include instances where unrepresented claimants have shown aggressive behavior, leading to altercations. I vividly recall a scenario where a claimant assaulted another claims representative in a men's restroom. Additionally, during a hearing, a claimant on the stand experienced a mental breakdown, demanded names of everyone present, and even pulled out surgical scissors and mace.
Conclusion
The working relationship between a lawyer and their client is a delicate balance of trust, communication, and understanding. While the potential risks are there, they can be mitigated with proper planning and awareness. As an attorney, I prioritize preparing my clients for both positive and negative outcomes and ensuring their safety and well-being throughout the legal process.