Introduction to the Late Intervention Scenario
The event of James I saving Severus from Sirius and Remus presents a critical juncture in the fictional narrative. This scenario prompts a deep dive into the potential outcomes if James was too late to intervene, focusing on the fates of Sirius, Remus, and Severus, and the ripple effects on the remaining characters.
The Fate of Sirius and Remus
Regardless of whether Sirius and Remus are killed or transformed into werewolves, the scenario introduces significant ethical and legal quandaries. As it stands, Dumbledore's decision to bring Remus to Hogwarts led to dire consequences. In this late intervention scenario, we explore whether James and Sirius might manage to save Remus, or whether the situation would still lead to tragic outcomes.
If Remus were to kill Sirius, it is logical to assume that James and Sirius would dispose of the body to protect their friend. However, if Sirius takes responsibility for the crime, Remus would certainly be horrified and devastated. This psychological toll on Remus could affect his mental health and well-being, making it difficult for him to move on from the situation.
The Potential Fate of Severus Snape
The late intervention scenario also introduces numerous possibilities for Severus Snape. If he is killed or transformed into a werewolf, rumors would likely spread, with Severus potentially becoming a Death Eater to escape his fate. Despite this, Dumbledore and the other knowledgeable individuals would be unaware, making Lily's situation even more complex.
Even if Snape is cursed instead, it raises questions about Dumbledore's actions. Would he believe that Snape and Remus could share the Shrieking Shack? Would he monitor the Marauders more closely to prevent any further harm? Alternatively, would the Marauders be viewed as a group attacking the 'outsider,' potentially leading to further trouble for Snape?
The Impact on Lily and James
The moral implications of being an accessory to murder could both alienate and unite James and Lily. James might lose interest in Lily due to the guilt they share, potentially pushing them further apart. However, it could also provide a platform for them to grow closer as they confront and deal with their shared past.
Severus, with fewer support systems, might be driven to adopt the pro-Dark rhetoric. His hopes and aspirations could be crushed, leading to depression or even suicidal thoughts. Alternatively, if he were ordered to hide his condition from Lily, the strain on his relationship could become even more intense, leading to a further deterioration of James' feelings towards him.
The Conclusion
Ultimately, the late intervention scenario offers a complex and multifaceted exploration of how one missed opportunity could set in motion a series of irreversible events. It highlights the interconnectedness of the characters and the far-reaching consequences of their actions. As the narrative continues, the late intervention scenario serves as a reminder of the weight and responsibility every character carries in shaping their world.