The Indestructible Thrash Metal Debate: Megadeth’s Rust in Peace versus Metallica’s Master of Puppets
When it comes to thrash metal, two iconic albums stand out: Megadeth's Rust in Peace and Metallica's Master of Puppets. These albums have been the subject of countless debates, each with its own unique characteristics and influences.
The Technical vs. Brutal Approach
At the heart of the debate is the differing approaches of these two albums. Rust in Peace is renowned for its technical complexity, while Master of Puppets exhibits a more brutal and raw style. The Puppet album has often been attributed with having a greater influence on the genre, but Rust in Peace is seldom overshadowed, especially due to its opening track, Holy Wars... The Desperation of Religion, which is considered an absolute masterpiece.
Which Album Won the Battle?
Some argue that Master of Puppets is the better album overall, citing its accessibility and commercial success, including being the first thrash album certified platinum. However, many fans and critics prefer Rust in Peace. Those who hold Rust in Peace in higher regard argue that it is superior in both lyrical and musical content, even ranking above Metallica's Master of Puppets.
The Legacy and Influence
Both albums are monumental contributions to thrash metal, with their songwriting and musicianship being highly regarded. Master of Puppets marked a significant moment for Metallica, being the first thrash album on a major label, and notably also signified the end of Cliff Burton, one of Metallica's most influential bassists. Megadeth's Rust in Peace has also left a lasting mark, especially during their 80s era.
Despite these contributions, some listeners find Rust in Peace to be a clear winner. This preference is often rooted in the technical prowess and complexity of the album, as well as its emotional depth and storytelling.
The Personal Standpoint
Personal opinions on these albums can vary widely. For those who are more partial to Megadeth, Rust in Peace is undeniably the standout. However, Master of Puppets remains a masterpiece in its own right, capturing the essence of thrash metal and setting a new standard for the genre.
In conclusion, while both Rust in Peace and Master of Puppets are esteemed as cornerstones in the thrash metal genre, Rust in Peace is often viewed as the technical and lyrical superior choice, while Master of Puppets continues to maintain its influence and commercial success.