The Impact of Robb Stark and Myrcella’s Marriage on the ‘A Song of Ice and Fire’ Universe
What would have been the consequences if Robb Stark had married Myrcella instead of Jeyne Westerling? This hypothetical scenario would have had far-reaching and complex ramifications for the world of Westeros, as explored in George R.R. Martin's 'A Song of Ice and Fire' series. Delve into the potential outcomes, genealogical changes, and the impact on key players and plotlines in this intricate analysis.
The Political Landscape of Westeros
Had Robb Stark chosen Myrcella Baratheon as his bride, the political landscape of Westeros would have been radically altered. Robb's decision to wed Jeyne Westerling instead of one of Walder Frey's daughters was a critical factor in the events of the Red Wedding, which saw the deaths of many Stark bannermen and allies. If Robb had married Myrcella, it's conceivable that Walder Frey would not have felt the need for such drastic measures and would have remained loyal to the Starks.
Much like the weak Baratheon claim to the Iron Throne, the marriage of Myrcella to Robb Stark would have further undermined the legitimacy of Joffrey Baratheon's claim. Myrcella, being Jaime Lannister's daughter, would have stood as a credible alternative claimant, potentially triggering a civil war and increasing instability within the realm. The Lannisters and the Starks may have formed an alliance to counter shared enemies, such as the Greyjoys or the Boltons, which could have dramatically altered the narrative trajectory of the series.
The Complexities of Westerosi Politics and Genealogy
Radiating from this central plot point, the marriage of Robb Stark and Myrcella would have introduced a cascade of genealogical shifts and political maneuvers. Assuming Myrcella was born in 284 A.C. and Robb unknowingly became a polygamist, both his wives could have been pregnant around the same time. In the realm of Westeros, the unexpected could lead to significant and unpredictable outcomes.
If Jeyne Westerling went north with the Blackfish while Myrcella was in Castle Black with Jon Snow, both could have given birth shortly after each other. The resulting offspring, Eddard and Robett (names chosen to maintain the traditional naming conventions), would have been born on opposing sides of the political divide, with Eddard potentially taking the title of the Starks or younger brother of Robb Stark.
Jon Snow, in this scenario, would claim the name Stark and marry Myrcella, marching with Stannis Baratheon to his banners and establishing a more sizable army than the 5,000 originally anticipated. This larger force could have shifted the balance of power, presenting the Boltons with a more formidable opponent. As Lord of Winterfell and Warden of the North, Jon may face familial conflicts as Robb Stark's sons come of age, leading to a contentious political situation.
Family Dynamics and Character Development
The character dynamics in both Winterfell and King's Landing would have experienced significant changes. Robb and Myrcella, driven by their shared blood and mutual love, would have crafted a bond that could have been seen as an extension of their families' fates. With Robb and Myrcella possessing Stark qualities—dark hair, grey eyes—they would have formed a unique connection, a blend of North and courtly intrigue. Eddard, embodying his grandfather's calm demeanor, and Brandon, born in grief with the 'Wolfs Blood', would have provided additional richness to the family's lineage and the narrative.
Moreover, if Stannis were to retake the south of the Neck, the legitimacy of Myrcella's claim to Casterly Rock would have given him a significant advantage over Cersei. This potential alliance could have shifted the power dynamics even further, leading to a more nuanced and complex storyline. The interplay between North and Crown would have introduced new layers of conflict, negotiation, and alliance-building, making the world of Westeros even more chaotic and impactful.
Conclusion
Reflecting on the hypothetical marriage of Robb Stark and Myrcella, it becomes evident that the world of 'A Song of Ice and Fire' would have been significantly altered. The implications of such a union extend beyond simple political maneuvering, touching upon the intricate genealogical ties, moral dilemmas, and familial bonds that shape the Westerosi narrative. The introduction of Eddard, Robett, and the potential for greater Northmen support under Stannis would have reshaped the political map, pushing the plot in unforeseen directions and adding new depth to the already rich storytelling of George R.R. Martin's masterpiece.