The Ethical Dilemma of Clonal Replaceability: Letting It Be or Self-Destruction?
The question of whether a better clone of yourself should replace you in your current life or be destroyed is a complex and thought-provoking ethical dilemma. In a world where life extension technology allows for the creation of effective clones, the idea of a clone surpassing its original in various aspects may seem daunting. But should we fear such a scenario or embrace it as a positive possibility?
Ignoring the Age Factor: A Scenario in Today’s Future
Let's set aside the age factor and imagine a utopian scenario where life extension technology is advanced enough to create effective clones. In this world, the concept of a clone 'replacing' the original may not be as absurd as it initially seems. The clone is its own unique individual, with its own set of experiences, skills, values, and memories. It is not a mere copy of the original, but rather a distinct entity.
The notion that a clone should replace the original is misguided. How can a clone be an authentic replacement when it lacks the personal history, unique experiences, and subjective feelings of the original? As such, the idea of a clone taking over the life of the original is fundamentally flawed.
Why Destruction is a Russell's Teapot
Why should the clone be destroyed instead? This mindset implies a zero-sum game where one person’s success is another’s failure. However, in a world full of others, people do not need to replace or destroy each other to succeed. They can coexist and find their own paths. A clone would also be a unique individual, capable of finding its own place in the world.
Reflecting on your current life, which aspects are you afraid of being replaced? For many, the prospect of a slightly different version of themselves is not necessarily daunting. Hanging out with a friend group from your clone would be inevitable, as the clone would share much of your experiences and values. If the clone is better in every way, it might even surpass you in the art of spontaneous combustion!
t ttttA clone appears, tttSpokes of the same sun, tttYet walk distinct paths. ttt
No matter how perfect the clone might be, the core of your being remains unique. Embrace the clone as a new journey, rather than an end to your own. If the clone is truly better in every way, it might just be a blessing. You could lead two separate lives, living your current life alongside the clone while following your heart's desires in the clone's life.
Conclusion: Embrace the Clonal Life
In conclusion, the idea of a clone replacing you should not be seen as a threat, but as an opportunity. Rather than fearing the clone or destroying it, consider letting it be. You could easily find ways to live alongside it, each of you fulfilling different roles in life. The fear of replacement is merely a self-imposed constraint; embracing the clone can open up new possibilities.