The Enigma of Four-Option Multiple Choice Questions: Why Four or Five?

Multiple choice questions (MCQs) are a ubiquitous form of assessment, found in educational and professional settings alike. If you've ever encountered a test that limits your options to four or five choices, you might have wondered, why not more or fewer?

Previous Perceptions and Reasons

Some might argue that the choice of four or five options is arbitrary. A previous response suggested that it is to confuse students who lack confidence, yet still attempt the questions. It was stated that this serves the purpose of filtering out less confident students and identifying the cream of the crop. Another response viewed this as a way to confuse aspirants and ensure that only the most confident and intelligent students succeed.

Multiple Choices to Find the Truth

Reflecting on my own experiences as a student, I noticed that most multiple choice questions had three wrong options and one correct answer. Initially, this seemed redundant, given that there were already three wrong answers. However, as an educator, I've come to understand the astute reasoning behind this practice.

The fundamental goal of providing multiple choice questions is not merely to test rote knowledge, but to foster a deeper understanding of the subject matter. By presenting multiple distractors (incorrect options), students are prompted to think critically, connect dots, and grapple with the nuances of the topic at hand.

Symbolic Relevance

A compelling analogy for this practice can be drawn from the Islamic tradition, specifically the ritual of Rami Jamarat during Hajj. This ritual involves stoning the three pillars representing the “Satans”, symbolizing the trials and temptations faced by the Prophet Ibrahim in his faithfulness to God.

The “Rami Jamarat” involves three stations: Jamarat al-Aqaba, Jamarat al-Wusta, and Jamarat al-Ula. At each station, pilgrims throw stones to represent the repulsion of Satan. This ritual underscores the struggle against negative temptations, which is symbolically reflected in the four-option MCQ format in education.

In the context of educational assessment, the four-option MCQ format can be seen as a “Ramah” (a type of punishment in the metaphorical sense, akin to the Jamarat stones) that humbles students by requiring them to distinguish the correct answer from multiple distractors. This process is akin to resisting the temptations symbolized by Satan in the Rami Jamarat ritual, thereby fortifying the core knowledge and values.

Key Takeaways:

The four-option MCQ format is designed to test critical thinking and deeper understanding, not just rote knowledge. The symbolic relevance of the four-option format is drawn from cultural and religious traditions, such as the Rami Jamarat ritual during Hajj. This format encourages students to think beyond surface-level information and engage with the substance of the subject matter.

By adopting a comprehensive understanding of the reason behind the four or five-option format in MCQs, educators can better appreciate the educational value of this assessment method. This understanding helps in formulating more effective and meaningful educational strategies and exam formats.

Upvote if you found this insight helpful share your thoughts in the comments!