The Debate: Who Is the Best Tarzan Actor?
The question of who is the best Tarzan actor has sparked countless debates among film enthusiasts. Suggestions range from the legendary Johnny Weissmuller to more recent picks like Bruce Bennett, with some even preferring Christopher Lambert. The debate is fueled by individual preferences and interpretations of the character created by Edgar Rice Burroughs (ERB).
The Golden Age: Johnny Weissmuller
For many, the answer is clear: Johnny Weissmuller is the only Tarzan. This Greek-American actor, known for his exceptional physical prowess, starred in the iconic Tarzan films released from 1932 to 1948. Weissmuller was an Olympic gold medalist in swimming and his athletic build and confident demeanor made him an ideal choice for the role. His portrayal is often cited for its authenticity and the ability to bring Tarzan to life in a way that was both respectful to the character and captivating to audiences.
The Controversy: Christopher Lambert and Gordon Scott
However, opinions vary widely. Some fans argue that Christopher Lambert, known for his role in the remake of Tarzan in 1984, is their personal favorite. Lambert brings a different kind of charisma and intensity to the role, particularly in Tarzan the Magnificent.
Others may not even be familiar with Gordon Scott, the actor known for five Tarzan films from 1938 to 1941. However, those who have seen his performances, especially in Tarzan's Greatest Adventure and Tarzan the Magnificent, often recommend him. Gordon Scott brings a unique blend of ruggedness and vulnerability to the role, making him a strong contender in the debate.
The Novel Approach: Bruce Bennett
For those who look for a Tarzan that closely aligns with the character created by ERB, Bruce Bennett might be the answer. Also known as Herman Brix, Bennett played Tarzan in a movie serial called The New Adventures of Tarzan in 1935 and was later featured in Tarzan and the Green Goddess using unused footage.
Bennett's portrayal is often praised for its enthusiasm and adherence to ERB's vision, bringing a sense of adventure and romance to the character that might be lacking in some other adaptations.
The Conclusion: A Personal Choice
Ultimately, the best Tarzan actor is a matter of personal preference. Each actor brings their own interpretation of the character, and what one audience member may adore, another may simply not connect with.
So, the next time you pick up a Tarzan movie or see one advertised, take a moment to reflect on your own preferences. Is it the legendary Weissmuller, the modern Lambert, the pioneering Gordon Scott, or perhaps the passionate Bruce Bennett? The debate continues, and the best Tarzan actor remains open to interpretation.