The Controversy Surrounding 'Han Shot First' in Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
The classic phrase 'Han shot first' in Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope has sparked debates among fans for decades. The original 1977 version and the 1997 re-release of the film present two distinct narratives regarding this pivotal scene, each with its own implications for Han Solo's character.
Original 1977 Version: Establishing Han as a Rogue Character
In the original 1977 version of A New Hope, Han Solo kills Greedo, a bounty hunter, without any warning in the Mos Eisley Cantina. This act established Han as a rogue character willing to take drastic measures for survival, aligning him as a morally ambiguous anti-hero. According to the original version, Han shot first, showcasing his readiness to defend himself and his own interests.
1997 Re-release: Changing the Narrative
The 1997 re-release of the film altered the scene, making it appear as though Greedo shoots at Han first, missing, and then Han returns fire in self-defense. While this change aimed to make Han's actions more understandable and sympathetic, it also shifted his character from that of an anti-hero to a more straightforward hero who only defends himself. This re-release is the version most people are familiar with today, thanks to the widespread availability of VCRs and later digital media.
Debate and Fan Opinion
The phrase 'That IS shooting first' highlights the ongoing debate among fans. Some argue that even if Greedo shot first, Han's refusal to appear before Jabba led to the confrontation, making Han responsible for the entire incident. Greedo clearly intended to turn Han into Jabba to settle a debt regarding a dumped shipment. Jabba would have likely forgiven Han and allowed him to continue with his mission. Thus, the argument goes, Han killed Greedo because he was willing to use violence to benefit himself.
Others maintain that 'Han shot first' is the only logical statement, owing to the timing of the shots being indiscernible in the original version. The quick succession of the shots, with Han firing just before the alien's blast, creates ambiguity. In the original film, Han holds his blaster underneath the table, firing incredibly swiftly. The change in the 1997 re-release was made to emphasize Han's self-defense, which aligns with George Lucas's intention to portray him as a defender rather than a cold-blooded killer. This alteration, however, was met with strong backlash from fans who are well aware of the original scene.
Conclusion: The Continued Controversy
Whether Han shot first in the original 1977 version or in the 1997 re-release, the debate continues among Star Wars fans. The phrase 'Han shot first' serves as a reminder of the significant changes made to the original film and the differing perspectives on Han Solo's character. For fans who cherish the original version, 'Han shot first' remains a badge of honor and a testament to the complexity of the beloved character.
Understanding the controversy and the reasons behind the changes in the film can provide a deeper appreciation of both versions and the evolution of one of cinema's most iconic scenes.