The Complexity of SNP's Position: Why It Sees Itself as Progressive Despite Nationalism Often Being Conservative

Manyconservatives might assume that the Scottish National Party (SNP) cannot be considered progressive given the nature of nationalism itself. However, this assumption underplays the nuanced and multifaceted nature of political ideologies. In this article, we explore why the SNP considers itself progressive despite the apparent contradiction.

Defining Terms: Progressive vs. Conservative

The word progressive is derived from the concept of progress, which inherently involves change and evolution. Progressives advocate for reforms and new policies to address contemporary issues and drive societal progress. On the other hand, a conservative political stance is rooted in the preservation of existing institutions and values. Broadly speaking, the term may refer to a preference for stability and continuity.

Given these definitions, it may seem paradoxical that the SNP, which advocates for the break up of the UK and the establishment of an independent Scottish state, considers itself as progressive. Yet, this perception is more complex than it appears at first glance.

Nationalism and Political Ideology

The term nationalism is often associated with the urge to preserve cultural, linguistic, or historical identity. Many interpretations of nationalism can be conservative, as they may defend traditional values and cultural heritage against perceived external threats. However, it is not inherently conservative. Nationalism can be used as a tool to advocate for progress and change, particularly when it involves the fight against imperialism and the dismantling of empires.

Scan through the available literature and you will find that Nationalism - Wikipedia does not assert that nationalism is necessarily conservative. Instead, it acknowledges that nationalism can be combined with various ideologies, including conservatism, national conservatism, and even socialism. There are numerous examples of left-wing nationalist movements that prioritize social justice and equal rights, which contradicts the notion that nationalism is solely a conservative ideology.

The SNP and Scottish Independence

The Scottish National Party (SNP) has long been championing the cause of Scottish independence, which is often viewed as a form of nationalism. However, contrary to the initial assumption, this does not make the SNP's position inherently conservative. The SNP aims to build a Scotland that is more progressive and equitable, addressing issues such as poverty, education, and healthcare, which many view as quintessential progressive goals.

Surprisingly, some conservatives might have assumed that all nationalists want to maintain the status quo, thus aligning with conservative principles. However, in the context of Scottish independence, the SNP is proposing a significant and transformative change that would provide a better future for Scotland. This is not merely a call for stability but for dynamic change that addresses the unique needs and aspirations of the Scottish people.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the SNP's self-identification as progressive is not contradictory considering the broader context of its political agenda. Nationalism, in its various forms, can certainly be used as a tool for progressive change. By advocating for Scottish independence and a more progressive Scotland, the SNP is engaged in a process of evolution, driven by the desire for a better and more inclusive future.

It's imperative to recognize that political ideologies are not monolithic and their reinterpretation can lead to nuanced and forward-thinking movements that challenge traditional labels. The SNP's position is a testament to the fluidity and adaptability of progressive thought in modern political discourse.