Should I Choose Columbia or NYU Tisch for Film School: A Comprehensive Guide
The choice between Columbia and NYU Tisch for your film school journey can be overwhelming, considering each institution's unique strengths and emphases. Columbia, an Ivy League school with a lower acceptance rate, and NYU Tisch are both renowned film programs, each with its own merits.
Why NYU Tisch Might Be the Way to Go
Alumni Success
NYU Tisch has a roster of incredible alumni who have shaped the film industry. Renowned filmmakers such as Martin Scorsese, Spike Lee, Chris Columbus, Oliver Stone, and Ang Lee have either studied or currently teach at the program. This network is invaluable for professional development and learning from those at the top of their field.
Focus on Technical Aspects of Filmmaking
NYU Tisch's program is well-known for its comprehensive technical training. For students interested in honing skills related to lighting, working with different lenses and cameras, and understanding the technical aspects of filmmaking, NYU Tisch offers an unparalleled learning environment. While both schools cover storytelling, NYU Tisch places a greater emphasis on technical proficiency, making it a top choice for those looking to delve into the technical side of filmmaking.
Proximity and Industry Network
Staying within Manhattan, particularly closer to Brooklyn, NYU Tisch offers a proximity advantage. As you walk to classes, you might bump into industry professionals more frequently. This geographic proximity can lead to networking opportunities, internships, and job placements. At NYU, you won't spend all your time on endless subway commutes, which can be both draining and distracting.
Why Columbia Might Be the Way to Go
Interdisciplinary Learning
Columbia University, while having a lower acceptance rate, offers a more interdisciplinary approach. If you're interested in studying film and other subjects, Columbia may be the perfect fit. Their renowned writing program, for instance, is rated highly and can complement your film studies. Columbia's environment encourages you to combine your passion for storytelling with other areas of interest, making it a versatile choice.
Strong Emphasis on Storytelling
Columbia's program focuses more on storytelling and writing. If you're more inclined to learn about the craft of writing scripts and serving as both a writer and director, Columbia would be a great choice. This emphasis on narrative and script development can be particularly beneficial for those with a strong interest in the written word and filmic storytelling.
Personal Perspective and Considerations
When deciding between these two prestigious institutions, consider the following aspects:
Meet the Students
When visiting colleges, it's crucial to meet the students in both programs. Feel a natural affinity with the students and the program's culture. At NYU Tisch, for example, you'll be working closely with fellow students on projects both in and outside of class, and you'll continue working alongside them post-graduation. The right cultural fit can significantly impact your educational experience and future career.
Cultural Fit
Each school has its unique atmosphere and teaching method. You need to find a cultural fit that aligns with your personal style and learning preferences. When I was making my choices, I felt an instant affinity with the students at USC's SCA, leading to my decision to attend.
Career Network
After graduation, your fellow students can become your strongest network. Consider the long-term relationships you'll form and the support system you'll have access to throughout your film career. NYU Tisch alumni often have a broader and more visible network within the film industry, which can be advantageous in your professional journey.
Conclusion
While both Columbia and NYU Tisch are top-notch film schools, your choice should align with your specific interests and learning goals. If you prioritize technical training and a well-established industry network, NYU Tisch might be the way to go. On the other hand, if you value interdisciplinary learning and a strong emphasis on storytelling, Columbia could be the better fit.