Rediscovering the Appeal of Sherlock Holmes and John Watson

As a keen researcher and fan of the Sherlock Holmes series, I often find myself pondering the enduring question: who is more lovable, Sherlock Holmes or John Watson?

After years of delving into the pages of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's works, I have come to the conclusion that Sherlock Holmes, despite his brilliance, is not particularly likable. How many times have we witnessed the disdaining manner in which he treats the Scotland Yard inspectors with whom he interacts? His interactions with Dr. John Watson, his seemingly close companion, are often fraught with acerbic remarks and biting criticism. The character of Holmes may be brilliant, but he lacks the warmth and empathy that make a truly compelling and likable hero.

Character Analysis of Sherlock Holmes

Often described as a "consulting detective," Sherlock Holmes demands the respect and attention of everyone around him. However, his lack of emotional warmth, his tendency to prioritize logic and deduction over human connection, and his disregard for other people's feelings make him an unsettling character. According to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Holmes states, "Your best friends would hardly call you a schemer, Watson," and later adds, "I never get to your limits. There are unexplored possibilities about you." These remarks, however interesting, highlight Holmes' cold and detached nature.

A Likeable Character: Dr. John Watson

On the other hand, John Watson is a character everyone can root for. Watson, with his kind heart and gentle demeanor, embodies the qualities that make us want to have him as a friend. Unlike Holmes, Watson is universally likeable. His role as a doctor and his companionship with Holmes add layers of depth to his character. He is a companion for afternoon chats over cigars at clubs and a reliable comrade at the races. His friendliness and sympathy are clear traits that distinguish him from the aloof brilliance of Holmes.

The True Heart of Watson

To understand Watson's true nature, one need only look into my own research. While working on my novel, Sherlock Holmes And The Sword Of Osman, I delved into the background notes of Dr. John Watson. During a train journey from East Sussex to London Charing Cross, I chanced upon a book by George Ewart Evans titled The Crooked Scythe. The introduction written by David Gentleman provided insight into Evans, a true-blue countryman. Gentlemen described Evans as an upright and vigorous person with an open and friendly manner, just like Dr. Watson himself. Evans' character traits of being sympathetic, generous, intelligent, shrewd, and unassertive reflect a perfect vision of Dr. Watson.

Friendship and Gentle Natures

It is this gentle nature that makes Watson relatable and endearing. Watson is the kind of person one would enjoy spending time with, discussing life, and providing support. Watson's character is a perfect blend of intelligence and straightforwardness, unlike Holmes' unwavering brilliance. This combination makes Watson a true likeable character in literature.

If you were to choose a friend in real life, would you prefer a brilliant but aloof mind like Holmes, or a gentle, kind heart like Watson? The answer becomes clear through the careful analysis of their respective characters. Watson is not only universally likeable but also beloved for his warm-hearted nature and his unwavering loyalty to his friend Holmes.

Keywords: Sherlock Holmes, John Watson, Character Analysis