How Does Sherlock Survive After Falling in the Waterfall?
The mystery of Sherlock Holmes' survival after falling into a waterfall in The Reichenbach Fall episode of the BBC series Sherlock has inspired many debates among fans. The episode plays a brilliant game with our expectations, using complex plot devices to maintain suspense and intrigue. Below, we break down the elaborate plan used by Sherlock to survive in the episode, explore the use of a bungee cord, and highlight the involvement of his allies.
The Fake Death
One of the most intriguing aspects of the episode is the elaborate plan designed by Holmes to fake his own death. This is a strategic move aimed at outmaneuvering his enemies, particularly Moriarty's associates. By feigned death, Sherlock temporarily thwarts Moriarty's plans and provides him with the necessary time to disappear and regroup, thus maintaining his survival.
The Use of a Bungee Cord
During the fall, a crucial detail that adds to the suspense is the implied use of a bungee cord or similar device. This apparatus is what breaks Sherlock's fall, preventing serious injury. The exact nature of the device and how it operates isn't revealed in the episode, adding an element of mystery that fuels speculation among viewers. Fans have theorized about the mechanics of such a device, with some suggesting it acts as a safety net or counterweight system.
Allies Involvement
The involvement of Sherlock's allies, notably Dr. John Watson, is pivotal to the success of his survival plan. Watson is misled into believing Sherlock is truly dead. This ensures that the illusion is maintained long enough for Sherlock to disappear and regroup. The trust between Sherlock and Watson is crucial, as it allows Watson to act in Sherlock's best interests without seeking retribution for his apparent death.
The Disappearing Act
After the fall, Sherlock goes into hiding, disappearing for several years to avoid Moriarty's network. This extended period of hiding provides him with the time to study and prepare for his return. During this time, Sherlock likely focuses on honing his skills and gathering information that will help him in future encounters with foes. This strategic retreat is a key component of his survival plan, further showcasing his exceptional intellect and resourcefulness.
The Revealing Questions
Some viewers have questioned the specifics of how Sherlock actually pulled off his survival. In the series, there isn't a direct explanation, and this ambiguity is intentional. The creators, Steve Moffat and Mark Gatiss, are known for their witty and complex storytelling. They likely believed that leaving the mechanics of Sherlock's survival unexplained added to the intrigue and allowed the audience to imagine their own solutions.
Doyle's Original Story
It's interesting to contrast this with Arthur Conan Doyle's original short story, "The Final Problem," where Sherlock Holmes has a different survival plan. In Doyle’s version, Holmes provides a detailed explanation of his elaborate suicide plan. He writes a farewell note and engages in a physical confrontation with Moriarty, ultimately using his skills in baritsu (likely meant to be Bartitsu, a real form of self-defense) to defeat Moriarty. However, his victory is short-lived as he faces a series of dangers from Moran's air gun before climbing back up the mountain.
While Doyle's explanation is more detailed, it doesn't offer a clear understanding of how Holmes survived. The ambiguity in the TV series seems to blend well with the mystique around the character. Moffat and Gatiss enjoyed playing with the audience's expectations and ensuring that much of Sherlock's survival remains a mystery, maintaining the element of surprise.
Conclusion
Whether it's through the use of a bungee cord or a series of strategic retreats, Sherlock Holmes' survival plan after the falls showcases his brilliant mind and resourcefulness. The episodic nature of the series allows for a gradual revelation of his survival, keeping the audience engaged and speculating until the final explanation. The mystery of how he survived adds a layer of complexity to his character, making him an even more intriguing figure for fans to explore.