SASR vs. Australian Commandos: An In-depth Comparison
When it comes to elite military units in Australia, the Special Air Service Regiment (SASR) and the Commandos often find themselves at the top of the list. Both units possess the skills and capabilities to handle some of the most challenging and dangerous operations. However, their roles and methodologies are distinct, much like a scalpel and a sledgehammer.
Tactical Roles and Characteristics
Traditionally, the Commandos have been identified as “shock troops.” Their mission often involves a rapid, overwhelming assault with the primary goal of seizing an objective swiftly and decisively. On the other hand, the SASR specializes in reconnaissance, providing intelligence and planning support to the Commandos. The SAS Troopers carefully scout the objective, meticulously plot the mission, and often provide detailed briefings to their fellow Commandos before taking a more stealthy approach, effectively hiding within inches of the enemy’s proximity.
While it's true that each group can effectively conduct the other's missions when necessary, their core roles remain distinct. This differentiation offers a layered approach to military operations, with each unit complementing the other and enhancing overall operational effectiveness.
Historical Context and Notable Operations
To truly appreciate the capabilities of both units, it's essential to explore their historical operations and equipment. One notable example is the “Krait” repeat raid, where approximately 300 kilometers of paddled journey back home nearly succeeded, leaving a lasting impact on those involved. The daring and unrelenting nature of these operations highlights the intense bravery and resilience of both SASR and Commandos.
The story of a submarine commander who missed the rendezvous and chose to suicide upon learning the truth is a darker reminder of the immense pressure these units face. These events underscore the emotional and psychological toll that such operations can have on the soldiers involved, even as they continue to defend their nation.
Operational Differences
From a civilian perspective, the skills of individual members from both units are at the highest level of proficiency. Both groups excel in marksmanship, tactical decision-making, and physical fitness. However, the ways in which they conduct their operations are vastly divergent.
For instance, a patrol of SAS might spend weeks in a hidden location, living in harsh conditions and conducting detailed reconnaissance behind enemy lines. Commandos, by contrast, are more likely to engage in high-visibility operations, conducting direct assaults with or without air and artillery support to capture high-value targets. This difference can be further understood by the saying: "I'd rather be roughed up by a platoon of commandos than a patrol of SAS. At least someone in the commandos' larger group would get bored and suggest a break later if the target was still around."
The SASR's LRRP (Long Range Reconnaissance Patrol) skills, often involving experiences such as tracking a dropped pig and converting it into tactical advantage, are a testament to their ability to operate in the most challenging environments. These units are known for their perseverance and relentless pursuit of objectives, even in the most trying conditions.
Shared Legacy and Insignia
A shared legacy is evident in the inclusion of the "Sykes-Fairbairn" knife as part of the insignia of both units. This versatile weapon has a rich history, dating back to World War I. In fact, during a period of research, I acquired a replica of the Canadian Pathfinder version, which proved as challenging to handle as it was to look at, as I accidentally impaled myself on the spiky pommel while reading books!
The choice to use a replica of this weapon as a bookmark also highlights the respect for tradition and the shared history among Australia's elite military units. Each unit has its own story and tradition, but collectively they stand as a testament to the nation's commitment to excellence in special operations.
Conclusion
While the SASR and the Commandos are often pitted against each other in debates, both units play a crucial and distinct role in ensuring Australia's national security. Their methods and operations are carefully tailored to the specific needs and environments they encounter. Whether it's the stealth and secrecy of the SASR or the direct and overwhelming force of the Commandos, both units are integral to maintaining Australia's defense capabilities.
Ultimately, it is the synergy between these two elite units that makes the Australian military a force to be reckoned with, rather than their individual strengths alone. Both groups are highly trained and capable, making them invaluable assets to their nation.