Robert Baratheon and the Love or Lack thereof for Cersei: An Analysis

Would Robert Baratheon have fallen in love with Cersei Lannister had he known the truth about Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen? This question delves into the characters' motivations, emotions, and the complex relationships within George R.R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire series.

The Dynamics of Robert's Love and Ego

Robert Baratheon's character is defined by his ego and his inability to see beyond his own desires. His relationship with Cersei was primarily driven by pragmatic considerations, such as her wealth and the political alliances her father, Tywin Lannister, could offer. This is evident in how Robert treated his first wife, even though he loathed her. He wanted a wife who was beautiful and kind, one who would be submissive and agree with his every whim, and who would not mind his infidelities.

Robb's True Feelings and the Role of Lyanna

The true relationship between Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen further complicates Robert's character. If he had known about Lyanna's relationship with Rhaegar, it is unlikely that this realization would have made him reconsider his feelings for Cersei. In fact, it would have strengthened his resentment towards Rhaegar and intensified his determination to retrieve Lyanna. As the narrative suggests, Robert's ego never would have allowed him to see the truth.

Ned's Loyalty and the Real Reason for the Mission

When we consider why Ned Stark took it upon himself to retrieve Lyanna, it becomes clear that it was not simply out of brotherly loyalty but also due to a fear that Robert would react violently to the truth. If Lyanna had revealed the truth to Robert, it is highly probable that he would have killed her. This underscores the stark reality of Robert's temperament and how he would have dealt with such knowledge.

Assuming the Relationship Between Rhaegar and Lyanna

It is also crucial to examine the nature of the relationship between Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark. Your assumption that their relationship was consensual lacks substantial evidence. The show and books provide no clear indications that the relationship was anything other than a violation of Lyanna's trust and autonomy. The narrative portrayal of this relationship suggests a power imbalance where Lyanna was controlled and used by Rhaegar, rather than two equals sharing a genuine connection.

The Inability to Love and Loyalty

Both Robert and Cersei are portrayed as characters who are unable to experience true love and loyalty, particularly in their relationships with women. Robert's infidelities and his treatment of his wife demonstrate a complete lack of caring and genuine affection. Similarly, Cersei's manipulative and selfish nature indicate her inability to form genuine connections.

Given these factors, it is likely that Robert's feelings for Cersei would have remained lukewarm or non-existent, as he would still be driven by his desire for political advantages and personal gain rather than genuine affection. The discovery of the truth about Lyanna and Rhaegar would likely fuel his resentment and further distance him from Cersei, rather than bringing them together.

In conclusion, Robert Baratheon's character is defined by his ego and a pragmatic approach to relationships, which makes it highly unlikely that he would have fallen in love with Cersei even if he knew the truth about Lyanna and Rhaegar. The nature of their relationships and the power dynamics at play make it clear that both were ultimately unable to experience true love and loyalty.