Reflections on The Walking Dead Season 9 Episode 5: A Good Send-Off for Rick Grimes?
As the dust settles on the events of The Walking Dead's ninth season, one episode in particular stands out: the concluding fifth episode. This installment, which has garnered both praise and criticism, leaves us reflecting on how the show bid goodbye to one of its most iconic characters. In this article, we delve into the merits and drawbacks of how the series wrapped up Rick Grimes' journey and explore how it might have been different.
Was the Send-Off Just Right?
One of the most compelling aspects of Season 9, Episode 5, was the reuniting of characters that Rick had lost track of, adding a layer of emotional depth to the farewell. It was evident that the scriptwriters aimed to honor Rick's character by showcasing his bravery and selflessness in saving his people once again. Yet, despite the moving reunions, the absence of one particular character left a lingering sense of incompleteness.
Carl, for instance, was notably absent, which some viewers found disappointing. The lack of reconciliation between father and son could have significantly impacted the emotional impact of the episode. This absence highlights the complexity of Rick's journey and how it might have been enriched by even a brief mention of Carl's experiences.
Death vs. Departure: A Harsher But More Engaging Farewell?
Some viewers, including myself, felt that a more definitive end for Rick would have been more impactful. The idea of Rick sacrificing himself could have offered a stark, yet fitting send-off, symbolizing his ultimate selflessness. However, the decision to keep Rick alive raises questions about the future narrative.
The question then is, how would the upcoming movies or future storylines be more successful if Rick had lived or died? By choosing to keep Rick alive, the writers and producers paved the way for a different kind of exploration in the film adaptation. The absence of his physical presence would allow for more creative storytelling, such as flashbacks and hallucinations, to highlight his significance to the group.
Analysis of Rick's Hallucination and Reunions
One of the standout elements of the episode was Rick's hallucinations, which provided a medley of best moments from his journey. These scenes, set in iconic locations, served as a heartfelt tribute to Rick's experiences. However, the inclusion of Sasha, and the ordering of her as his third choice in his hallucinations, raised questions about the reasoning behind this decision.
The season-long partnership between Rick and Sasha, while strong, did not have the same depth as his bond with other characters like Tyreese. Tyreese, in fact, had a significant fight with Rick at the prison but still maintained a mutual respect. This raises the question of why Sasha's character was chosen for this important moment, suggesting that it might have been easier to cast her rather than someone more meaningful to Rick.
Characters like Glenn, who saved his life in Atlanta, and Carl, his son, could have provided deeper emotional resonance in a tribute to Rick. Additionally, Lori, who played a pivotal role in his life, also deserved an inclusion.
Conclusion: A Decent Send-Off, but Room for Improvement
Ultimately, while the send-off for Rick Grimes was executed well and provided a poignant ending to Andrew Lincoln's portrayal, it also left room for ongoing discussion. By revisiting these moments and reflecting on the choices made, fans and critics alike can gain a deeper understanding of the narrative and Rick's character.
TheARING FORM these reflections, the episode stands as a fitting but perhaps incomplete send-off. Rick's journey continues in the upcoming films, leaving fans eager to explore how his life might unfold without him, a truly intriguing prospect for any fan of The Walking Dead.