Reflections on Never Trump Conservatives and the State of American Conservatism
The recent discussion on the Never Trump movement has sparked a range of thoughts among conservatives. It is not uncommon for conservative voices to observe that while some high-profile conservatives such as David Brooks, David French, Jonah Goldberg, and George Will align themselves with the Never Trump stance, others support President Trump. This dichotomy often leads to questions about the direction and principles of conservatism in today's political landscape.
Understanding the Divide
Many conservative thinkers argue that the divide between Never Trump conservatives and Trump supporters reflects a broader struggle within the Republican Party. Some conservatives see Trump as a symbol of the radical left's infiltration and dominance, while others believe his policies and actions do not align with traditional conservative values. It is a reflection of the complex internal dynamics within American politics that often devolve into personal and intellectual conflicts.
The Elephant in the Room: The State of Conservatism in the 21st Century
It is essential to distinguish between conservatism and political cunning or strategic alliances. Trump himself was a liberal who used conservative rhetoric to gain support. This confusion has obscured the true essence of conservatism, leading to a misalignment of principles and rhetoric. According to some intellectuals like Friedrich Hayek, liberal social goals, represented by both Republicans and Democrats, often prioritize collective social and economic goals, which can be at odds with conservative beliefs in individual freedom and limited government.
The Core Principles of Conservatism
At its core, conservatism aims to preserve traditional values and the principles of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence. It is about maintaining a strict interpretation of these foundational documents and promoting individual liberty over state intervention. Whilst many popular conservatives have traditionally supported Trump, there is a growing recognition that his policies and actions have strayed from these principles. This shift has prompted discussions about the future of conservatism and the importance of adhering to foundational values.
A Family Squabble?
Regarding the Never Trump movement, many conservatives view it more as a family squabble within the Republican Party, rather than a broader ideological conflict. Names like George Will, who has written extensively on political and social issues, David Brooks, and David French reflect a range of intellectual stances within the movement. While some may see them as timid or complacent, others view their critique as a necessary voice in aligning the party with conservative principles. The support or opposition to Trump from these conservative thinkers highlights the diversity of thought within the movement.
Conclusion: The Path Ahead for Conservatism
The fight over Never Trump is a testament to the complexity and fragmentation of American politics. As we navigate this landscape, it is crucial for conservatives to reaffirm their commitment to the principles of individual freedom, limited government, and strict constitutional interpretation. Whether it is through support or criticism, the current debates offer an opportunity for reflection and reaffirmation of core values. The future of conservatism lies in the ability to remain true to its principles while engaging with the realities of modern politics.
References
Hayek, Friedrich. (1944). The Road to Serfdom. Routledge.