Preserving B-17 Bombers: Risk and Value

Introduction

The loss of a B-17 at the Dallas air show in 2019 was a tragic event, prompting questions about the number of airworthy B-17s and whether it is worth the risk of these historic aircraft in air shows. This article will explore the current state of B-17s, their historical and educational value, and the risks involved in flying these aircraft.

The Current State of B-17s

According to recent reports, there are only approximately 45 complete B-17 models left, out of which only nine are airworthy. This makes the preservation of these aircraft a matter of extreme importance.

The recent crash at the air show was caused by human error, including improper maintenance and pilot error, not due to the age or deterioration of the aircraft. This emphasizes the importance of proper maintenance and attention to detail, which are critical for the safe operation of these historic planes.

Historical and Educational Value

The B-17 is not just a piece of metal; it is an integral part of history. These planes served as the backbone of the Allied war effort during World War II. Their flights offer a tangible experience that cannot be replicated in museums or through digital media.

While museums serve an important role in preserving and showcasing these artifacts, there is a unique value in flying these planes. The deep rumble and the sights and sounds of a flying B-17 cannot be fully appreciated in a static display. These experiences remind us of the sacrifices made by those who flew these planes.

Risks vs. Benefits

The risks associated with flying B-17s are significant, but they are outweighed by the benefits. There will come a time when it will no longer be possible to fly these aircraft, and that time is already approaching. As the people who built, flew, and maintained these planes get older, the knowledge and parts required to keep them flying diminish.

Keeping these aircraft flying is a matter of maintaining a living history. The Commemorative Air Force (formerly the Confederate Air Force) has been flying old warbirds for many years, and their expertise in maintaining these planes is invaluable. Despite the risks, they continue to strive to preserve this aspect of history.

Alternatives to Flying B-17s

Museums and private collections are home to many more B-17s than are currently airworthy. This means that there are many opportunities for people to view and learn about these aircraft without risking a flight. However, there is a unique appeal to seeing a B-17 in the air, where the full experience of the plane can be appreciated.

The difference between a flying B-17 and a static display is akin to the difference between a live bird and a stuffed one. The former offers a dynamic and visceral experience that cannot be fully replicated in any other way.

Concluding Thoughts

While the loss of a B-17 is tragic, the value of keeping these historic aircraft flying cannot be understated. The importance of preserving this part of history should not be underestimated. As long as proper safety measures are in place, and the risks are minimized, the flying of B-17s should continue.

It is clear that the number of airworthy B-17s is dwindling, and we should cherish and protect what remains. These historic aircraft are irreplaceable and offer a unique opportunity to experience a piece of history in a way that nothing else can.