Introduction to Phantom of the Opera
Phantom of the Opera, created by Andrew Lloyd Webber, is one of the most beloved and controversial musicals in modern opera history. Its blend of dramatic storytelling and popular musical elements has captivated audiences worldwide, yet it has also sparked debates within the musical community. This article delves into the opinions of opera enthusiasts, examining their perspectives on this enigmatic masterpiece.

Opinions of Opera Enthusiasts

Trashing Other Genres

It is not uncommon for the music community to offer critiques of certain genres, labelling them as inferior or "schlocky" compared to classical compositions. This includes works by Andrew Lloyd Webber and the likes of Kenny G, and even popular music in general. These critiques often stem from a desire to feel superior and viewed as better musicians. However, it's important to appreciate all forms of music as sacred and find value in their unique attributes.

Phantom of the Opera andIts Appeal

Despite the genre criticism, many opera lovers still cherish Phantom of the Opera. They appreciate its simple dramatic music and the emotions it evokes. Andrew Lloyd Webber's works, such as Jesus Christ Superstar and Cats, are also celebrated for their originality, though Jesus Christ Superstar holds a special place in their hearts due to its profound musical and lyrical brilliance. The accessibility and populism of Phantom, while perhaps less complex than some operatic masterpieces, make it appealing to a broader audience.

Personal Reflections

When reflecting on Phantom of the Opera, many opera singers find themselves swayed by its charm. The main actor or singer in a particular production is often praised for their talent. Some recall a memorable standing ovation by the audience, highlighting the emotional impact of the performance. However, the appeal varies, and some find the musical too common and poppy, deeming it less appealing than choir productions or more complex operas like Rinaldo.

Unique Perspectives

Some individuals hold a positive view of Phantom of the Opera, considering it a masterpiece in its own right. They acknowledge the talent of the main performers, often remarking on the distinctive and impressive performances, such as an Asian Disney princess-like portrayal that charmed the audience. This example underscores the unique and captivating nature of the musical, capable of surprising and enchanting even the most discerning of opera lovers.

For example, one experienced performer mentioned their own appreciation for a production of Phantom of the Opera, describing it as a masterful performance. The description of the main female actor's appearance as akin to an Asian Disney princess and her receiving a standing ovation, exemplify the emotional power of the musical and the admiration it can inspire.

Another individual also had a profound experience, watching a baroque production of Handel's Rinaldo by the Collegium 1704, expressing that they enjoyed it as much as the Phantom of the Opera of that same night. Both performances are treated with equal reverence, reflecting the diverse experiences and tastes within the musical world.

Conclusion
Ultimately, the interpretation of Phantom of the Opera varies widely among opera lovers. While some find it enchanting and masterful, others may prefer the complexity and profoundness of other operatic works. Regardless of personal preferences, it is important to appreciate the unique qualities that make Phantom of the Opera a significant and beloved addition to the musical world.