Neville Longbottom as the Chosen One: Alternatives in Fan Fiction

In the vast and imaginative world of Harry Potter fan fiction, authors often explore alternative scenarios and character dynamics. One such intriguing idea involves Neville Longbottom taking on the role of the Chosen One, a role traditionally attributed to Harry Potter. This article explores the possible outcomes and alternative fan fiction scenarios where Neville steps up to the challenge.

Would Voldemort Pursue Neville?

The question of why Voldemort wouldn't pursue Neville as the Chosen One is a common point of discussion. Many theorists argue that Voldemort's focus on Harry stems from his belief in blood purity and his specific fascination with the Potter family name. If Neville, who also had a connection to Voldemort through his mother's connection to Salazar Slytherin, were the Chosen One, Voldemort might indeed target him.

Potential Relationships and Outcomes

Imagine a world where Neville takes on the role of the Chosen One. Here are some potential scenarios:

Voldemort's Attentions: Had Voldemort decided to pursue Neville, the dynamics of the story would drastically change. Leaders like Severus Snape, who originally sided with both sides, might have a more challenging stance. Snape, who might still be a member of the Death Eaters, would find himself in a precarious position, torn between his loyalty to Voldemort and his growing affection for Neville. Marriage Choices: Interestingly, the marriage dynamics would shift. Perhaps Neville would marry Ginny Weasley, strengthening the bond between the Longbottoms and the Weasleys. This union could introduce new character dynamics and storylines, potentially leading to a more united and resilient wizarding community. Ms. Norris and Other Victims: In this alternate universe, Ms. Norris (who is the cat belonging to Nearly Headless Nick) might not have been petrified. This could introduce new challenges and plot twists, as the house-elves and other characters might need to protect Neville from Voldemort's shadow. Harry and Hermione’s Future: Given Neville’s new role, the romantic and professional journeys of Harry and Hermione might evolve differently. Harry might instead marry Luna Lovegood, bringing a new dynamic to the trio. Neville and Hermione could potentially end up together, starting a family of their own, introducing a new generation of witches and wizards into the magical world.

Arguments For Neville's Potential as the Chosen One

Matthew Lewis, a renowned actor, believes that Neville has the capability to handle the role of the Chosen One. He argues that Neville is quite powerful in his own right, possessing a strength and resilience that would have been nurtured by his friends and classmates, much like Harry’s support system. Neville's significant contribution to the battle in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows further supports this theory, highlighting his unexpected bravery and power.

Exploring Fan Fiction

While the Harry Potter fandom is filled with countless fan fiction works, there have been few where Neville takes on the role of the Chosen One. These stories offer a fresh perspective on the wizarding world and challenge the established narrative. The idea is intriguing due to the potential outcomes, from Voldemort's pursuit to the evolving relationships and dynamics within the wizarding community.

As the Harry Potter universe continues to captivate fans, the exploration of alternative scenarios and character development remains a fertile ground for fan fiction writers. Whether one agrees with the hypothesis or not, contemplating these "what if" scenarios adds a layer of complexity and enjoyment to the beloved series.

Keywords: Neville Longbottom, Chosen One, Fan Fiction